Planning register

Planning Application - 16/01563/F

Skip to tab headings. Skip to tab content.

Application Number
16/01563/F
Application Type
Full Development
Status
Application Refused
Decision Level
Committee
Location
Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY
Proposal
Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping ((revised scheme of 15/01693/F)
Parish
Sibford Gower
Ward
Cropredy, Sibfords And Wroxton
Received Date
03/08/2016
Valid Date
04/08/2016
Weekly List Date
Comments Due Date
08/09/2016
Target Decision Date
03/11/2016
Committee Date
27/10/2016
Decision
Refused
Decision Issued Date
01/11/2016
Appeal Received Date
04/04/2017
Appeal Start Date
Appeal Decision
Appeal Allowed
Appeal Decision Date
31/10/2017
Applicant
Mr & Mrs Gregory Besterman
Applicant's Address
C/o Carter Jonas Ms Clare O'Hanlon Mayfield House 256 Banbury Road Summertown OX2 7DE
Agent
Carter Jonas
Agents's Address
Ms Clare O'Hanlon Mayfield House 256 Banbury Road Summertown OX2 7DE

Written comments are publicly available and cannot be treated as confidential. Please refer to our Comment on a Planning Application page for further information. To view representations received please refer to the documents tab.


Neighbour List
Address Consult Date Reply Due Reply Received Re-Consult Date Reply Due Reply Date
Address Consult Date Reply Due Reply Received15/09/2016 Re-Consult Date Reply Due Reply Date15/09/2016
AddressHolmby House Main Street Sibford Ferris Oxfordshire OX15 5RG Consult Date Reply Due Reply Received07/09/2016 Re-Consult Date Reply Due Reply Date07/09/2016
Address Consult Date Reply Due Reply Received23/09/2016 Re-Consult Date Reply Due Reply Date23/09/2016
AddressCotswold House College Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Consult Date12/08/2016 Reply Due02/09/2016 Reply Received Re-Consult Date Reply Due Reply Date
AddressNew Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Consult Date12/08/2016 Reply Due02/09/2016 Reply Received13/09/2016 Re-Consult Date Reply Due Reply Date13/09/2016

Consultee List
Name Address Consult Date Reply Due Reply Received Type
NameConservation (CDC) Address Consult Date12/08/2016 Reply Due26/08/2016 Reply Received20/09/2016 TypeStandard Consultee
NameContaminated Land (CDC) Address Consult Date12/08/2016 Reply Due26/08/2016 Reply Received21/09/2016 TypeStandard Consultee
NameLandscapes Officer - Landscape Services (CDC) AddressInformal Open Space/Play Facilities Consult Date12/08/2016 Reply Due26/08/2016 Reply Received31/08/2016 TypeStandard Consultee
NameLocal Highways Authority OCC Address Consult Date12/08/2016 Reply Due26/08/2016 Reply Received08/09/2016 TypeStandard Consultee
NameSibford Gower Parish Council Address74 Beaulieu Close Banbury OX16 4FQ Consult Date12/08/2016 Reply Due02/09/2016 Reply Received30/08/2016 TypeStandard Consultee
Public Notices
Description Display Date Expiry Date Notice Type
DescriptionSite Notice General Display Date Expiry Date Notice Type
DescriptionBanbury Guardian Display Date18/08/2016 Expiry Date08/09/2016 Notice Type

To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.

Document Type Date Description File Size Drawing/Rev Number
Application Forms
Application Document 09/08/2016 App form (0kb) -
Application Document 12/08/2016 Publicity (0kb) -
Application Document 09/08/2016 Neighbour Map (0kb) -
Application Document 09/08/2016 Neighbour Consults (0kb) -
Application Document 09/08/2016 Property History (0kb) -
Application Document 09/08/2016 Info Map (Arc) (0kb) -
Application Document 09/08/2016 Checklist (0kb) -
Supporting Documents
Photographs 09/08/2016 Location Precedent Photographs (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/08/2016 Planning statement (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/08/2016 Bat Survey (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/08/2016 Design & Access statement (0kb) -
Site Plans
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout 09/08/2016 Existing site plan (0kb) -
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout 20/10/2016 AMD Proposed site plan (0kb) -
Site Location Plan 09/08/2016 Location plan (0kb) -
Existing Plans
Plans – Sections/Surveys 09/08/2016 Permitted development extenstions to existing dwelling survey (0kb) -
Proposed Plans
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Existing stable 2 plans & elevations (0kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Proposed stable 4 elevations (0kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Existing stable 4 plans & elevations (0kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Existing stable 3 plans & elevations (0kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Existing stable 2 plans & elevations (0kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Existing stable 1 plans & elevations (0kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Existing farmhouse plans & elevations (0kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 09/08/2016 Conversion of existing building to stabling (0kb) -
Plans – Details 09/08/2016 Planning dormer detail (0kb) -
Plans – Details 09/08/2016 Planning window detail (0kb) -
Plans – Details 09/08/2016 Muddle barn photo locations (0kb) -
Plans – Landscape 09/08/2016 Landscape proposals (0kb) -
Plans – Miscellaneous 04/10/2016 Proposed sketch second floor/roof plan (0kb) -
Plans – Miscellaneous 04/10/2016 AMD proposed sketch ground/first floor (0kb) -
Plans – Miscellaneous 04/10/2016 AMD Proposed sketch elevations (0kb) -
Public Comments
Public Comments 13/09/2016 Philip, G and K - 12.09.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 23/09/2016 Butt, R - 22.09.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 08/09/2016 Wass, J 07.09.2016 (0kb) -
Public Comments 15/09/2016 Sabin, B, J and C - 14.09.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 23/09/2016 Butt R - 07-09-16 (0kb) -
Consultee Responses
Consultation Response 03/11/2016 Sibford Gower Parish Council 17/8/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 27/09/2016 Environmental Protection 22/9/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 15/09/2016 Landscape architect 31-08-16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 01/09/2016 Sibford Ferris PC 30-08-16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 13/09/2016 Sibford Gower PC 10-09-16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 08/09/2016 OCC Highways 28/9/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 22/09/2016 Design & Conservation 20-09-16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 21/09/2016 Contaminated Land - 21.09.16 (0kb) -
Officer/Committee Consideration
Officer Report 01/11/2016 27.10.2016 (0kb) -
Appeal Documents
Appeal Documents 13/06/2017 3rd party comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 13/06/2017 3rd party comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 13/06/2017 3rd party comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 13/06/2017 3rd party comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 13/06/2017 PINS notice of 3rd party comments 12/06/17 (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 31/10/2017 PINS notice of appeal decision 31/10/17 (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 27/06/2017 PINS notice of appellant final comments 27/06/17 (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 08/05/2017 Saved policies (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 08/05/2017 Saved policies (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 08/05/2017 Constraints map (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 08/05/2017 Consultation responses (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 08/05/2017 Neighbour list / responses (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 08/05/2017 Appeal letter (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 08/05/2017 PINS notice of appeal start date 04/05/17 (0kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 27/06/2017 Appellant final comments (0kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 08/05/2017 Appellant report LVIA (0kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 08/05/2017 Appellant statement of case (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 13/06/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix A (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 13/06/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix A (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 13/06/2017 LPA Statement of case (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 13/06/2017 LPA Statement of case (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 NFFP - Para 17 - 55 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 NFFP - Para 17 - 55 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 Local Plan 1996 - H17 - H18 - C30 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 Local Plan 1996 - H17 - H18 - C30 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 LPA Questionnaire (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 08/05/2017 Appellant appeal form (0kb) -
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision 31/10/2017 Appeal Decision - Appeal Allowed 31/10/17 (0kb) -
Decision 01/11/2016 01.11.2016 (0kb) -
Planning Application Documents
Superseded 09/08/2016 SUPP Proposed sketch elevations (0kb) -
Superseded 09/08/2016 SUPP Proposed sketch second floor & roof plan (0kb) -
Superseded 09/08/2016 SUPP Proposed sketch ground & first floor (0kb) -
Superseded 09/08/2016 SUPP Proposed site plan (0kb) -
Superseded 04/10/2016 SUPP AMD Proposed site plan (0kb) -
Application Forms
Application Document (0kb) - App form
Application Document (0kb) - Publicity
Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour Map
Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour Consults
Application Document (0kb) - Property History
Application Document (0kb) - Info Map (Arc)
Application Document (0kb) - Checklist
Supporting Documents
Photographs (0kb) - Location Precedent Photographs
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Planning statement
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Bat Survey
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Design & Access statement
Site Plans
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (0kb) - Existing site plan
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (0kb) - AMD Proposed site plan
Site Location Plan (0kb) - Location plan
Existing Plans
Plans – Sections/Surveys (0kb) - Permitted development extenstions to existing dwelling survey
Proposed Plans
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Existing stable 2 plans & elevations
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Proposed stable 4 elevations
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Existing stable 4 plans & elevations
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Existing stable 3 plans & elevations
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Existing stable 2 plans & elevations
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Existing stable 1 plans & elevations
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Existing farmhouse plans & elevations
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Conversion of existing building to stabling
Plans – Details (0kb) - Planning dormer detail
Plans – Details (0kb) - Planning window detail
Plans – Details (0kb) - Muddle barn photo locations
Plans – Landscape (0kb) - Landscape proposals
Plans – Miscellaneous (0kb) - Proposed sketch second floor/roof plan
Plans – Miscellaneous (0kb) - AMD proposed sketch ground/first floor
Plans – Miscellaneous (0kb) - AMD Proposed sketch elevations
Public Comments
Public Comments (0kb) - Philip, G and K - 12.09.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Butt, R - 22.09.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Wass, J 07.09.2016
Public Comments (0kb) - Sabin, B, J and C - 14.09.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Butt R - 07-09-16
Consultee Responses
Consultation Response (0kb) - Sibford Gower Parish Council 17/8/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Environmental Protection 22/9/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Landscape architect 31-08-16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Sibford Ferris PC 30-08-16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Sibford Gower PC 10-09-16
Consultation Response (0kb) - OCC Highways 28/9/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Design & Conservation 20-09-16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Contaminated Land - 21.09.16
Officer/Committee Consideration
Officer Report (0kb) - 27.10.2016
Appeal Documents
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd party comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd party comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd party comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd party comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of 3rd party comments 12/06/17
Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appeal decision 31/10/17
Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appellant final comments 27/06/17
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved policies
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved policies
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Constraints map
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Consultation responses
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Neighbour list / responses
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Appeal letter
Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appeal start date 04/05/17
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant final comments
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant report LVIA
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant statement of case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix A
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix A
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - NFFP - Para 17 - 55
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - NFFP - Para 17 - 55
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 - H17 - H18 - C30
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 - H17 - H18 - C30
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Questionnaire
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Appellant appeal form
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision (0kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Allowed 31/10/17
Decision (0kb) - 01.11.2016
Planning Application Documents
Superseded (0kb) - SUPP Proposed sketch elevations
Superseded (0kb) - SUPP Proposed sketch second floor & roof plan
Superseded (0kb) - SUPP Proposed sketch ground & first floor
Superseded (0kb) - SUPP Proposed site plan
Superseded (0kb) - SUPP AMD Proposed site plan
Addresses
Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY

Planning Applications

Application number Valid Date Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Issued Date
15/01693/F 15/09/2015 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping (revised scheme of 14/02157/F) Application Withdrawn 25/02/2016
16/01563/F 04/08/2016 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping ((revised scheme of 15/01693/F) Refused 01/11/2016
16/00064/SO 04/08/2016 Screening Opinion Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Screening Opinion to Application 16/01563/F - Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping (resubmission 15/01693/F) Screening Opinion not requesting EIA 25/08/2016
14/01100/CLUE 03/07/2014 Certificate of Lawful Use Existing Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Certificate of Lawful Use Existing - Use of dwelling in breach of Condition 5 (Agricultural Occupancy) CHN600/85 Permitted 27/08/2014
14/00107/SO 05/01/2015 Screening Opinion Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Screening Opinion - Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping
15/00089/SO 15/09/2015 Screening Opinion Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Screening Opinion to 15/01693/F - Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping (revised scheme of 14/02157/F) Screening Opinion not requesting EIA 05/10/2015
14/02157/F 05/01/2015 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping Application Withdrawn 20/04/2015
18/00616/F 10/04/2018 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Variation of Condition 2 (Plans) of 16/01563/F and Appeal ref: APP/C3105/W/17/3173098 Permitted 10/07/2018
17/00191/CLUP 25/01/2017 Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Certificate of Lawfulness of Proposed Development for extensions and alterations to the existing dwellinghouse and new ancillary building. Permitted 22/03/2017
18/00358/DISC 03/09/2018 Discharge Of Conditions Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Discharge of Conditions 3 (dormers), 4 (materials), 5 (stone sample), 6 (doors and windows), 7 (FFLs), 10 (tree survey), 15 (badger check), 16 (Biodiversity enhancement) and 18 (access) of 18/00793/F Permitted 16/11/2018
17/00259/HPA 25/01/2017 Householder Prior Approval Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Single storey rear extension - height to eaves 2.4m, length 8m, overall height 3.8m Prior Approval Not Required 03/03/2017
18/00793/F 09/05/2018 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Variation of Condition 2 (plans) of 16/01563/F (Appeal reference - APP/C3105/W/17/3173098) - minor material amendments involving alterations to the design of the replacement dwelling as well as the construction of a replacement outbuilding Permitted 08/08/2018
18/01167/F 29/06/2018 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Creation of new driveway and part removal of existing driveway Permitted 09/11/2018
18/00037/SO 09/05/2018 Screening Opinion Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Variation of condition 2 (plans) of 16/01563/F (Appeal reference - APP/C3105/W/17/3173098) - minor material amendments involving alterations to the design of the replacement dwelling as well as the construction of a replacement outbuilding Screening Opinion not requesting EIA 22/05/2018
19/01387/F 19/07/2019 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Variation of Condition 2 (plans) of 16/01563/F - alterations to the design of the replacement dwelling, the erection of a replacement outbuilding, provision of a new 2m high wall and demolition of two bays of a stable building Permitted 09/12/2019
19/02372/DISC 11/11/2019 Discharge Of Conditions Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower OX15 5RY Discharge of Condition 8 (hard and soft landscape works) of 19/01387/F Permitted 29/01/2020
20/01086/F 05/05/2020 Full Development Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower OX15 5RY Alterations and conversion of existing stable building to provide a gym and swimming pool and change of use of land to amenity land, providing tennis court associated with dwellinghouse replacing existing manège Permitted 30/06/2020
20/02176/DISC 11/08/2020 Discharge Of Conditions Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower OX15 5RY Discharge of Condition 9 (tree pits) of 19/01387/F Permitted 12/10/2020
22/00919/EL 28/03/2022 Electricity Notification Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Upgrading 4.6 kilometers of high voltage overhead line from single phase (2 wire) to three phase (3 wire). Observations 09/05/2022

Appeal Applications

Appeal number Appeal Start Date Appeal Type Location Proposal Decision
17/00020/REFAPP 04/05/2017 Appeal against Refusal Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping ((revised scheme of 15/01693/F) Appeal Allowed

Building Control Applications

Application number Received Date Validated Date Application Type Location Proposal
18/00957/DOMFP 24/08/2018 06/09/2018 Full Plans Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Building of a replacement dwelling and outbuilding
CP/OFTEC/00129/2017 14/09/2017 14/09/2017 Oil Firing Technical Association Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY Install an oil storage tank

Back to top.