Track this application
| Application Number 14/02157/F |
Application Type Full Development |
| Status Application Withdrawn |
Decision Level Committee |
| Location Muddle Barn Farm
Colony Road
Sibford Gower
Banbury
OX15 5RY |
|
| Proposal Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping |
|
| Parish Sibford Gower |
Ward Sibford |
| Received Date 29/12/2014 |
Valid Date 05/01/2015 |
| Weekly List Date |
Comments Due Date 12/02/2015 |
| Target Decision Date 06/04/2015 |
Committee Date 16/04/2015 |
| Decision Application Withdrawn |
Decision Issued Date 20/04/2015 |
| Appeal Received Date |
Appeal Start Date |
| Appeal Decision |
Appeal Decision Date |
| Applicant Mr And Mrs Gregory Besterman |
| Applicant's Address Muddle Barn Farm
Colony Road
Sibford Gower
Banbury
OX15 5RY |
|
Agent
Carter Jonas LLP
|
|
Agents's Address
Mr Kevin Ayrton
Mayfield House
256 Banbury Road
Summertown, Oxford
OX2 7DE
|
Written comments are publicly available and cannot be treated as confidential. Please refer to our Comment on a Planning Application page for further information. To view representations received please refer to the documents tab.
Neighbour List
| Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AddressHolmby House Main Street Sibford Ferris Oxfordshire OX15 5RG | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received25/02/2015 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date25/02/2015 |
| AddressCollege Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Oxfordshire OX15 5RY | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received31/01/2015 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date31/01/2015 |
| AddressTemple Mill Woodway Road Sibford Ferris Oxfordshire OX15 5DA | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received12/02/2015 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date12/02/2015 |
| AddressCotswold House College Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due04/02/2015 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| AddressNew Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due04/02/2015 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
Consultee List
| Name | Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NameAppropriate Parish Council | Address | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due04/02/2015 | Reply Received27/01/2015 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameContaminated Land | Address | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due28/01/2015 | Reply Received | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameEcology (CDC) | Address | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due28/01/2015 | Reply Received05/03/2015 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameLandscapes Officer - Landscape Services (CDC) | AddressInformal Open Space/Play Facilities | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due28/01/2015 | Reply Received16/02/2015 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameLocal Highways Authority OCC | Address | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due04/02/2015 | Reply Received | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameSevern Trent Water Ltd | AddressLeicester Water Centre Gorse Hill Anstey Leicester LE7 7GU | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due04/02/2015 | Reply Received21/01/2015 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameUrban Design (CDC) | Address | Consult Date14/01/2015 | Reply Due28/01/2015 | Reply Received | TypeStandard Consultee |
| Description | Display Date | Expiry Date | Notice Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| DescriptionMAJOR DEVELOPMENT UNDER GDO | Display Date | Expiry Date | Notice Type |
| DescriptionBanbury Guardian | Display Date22/01/2015 | Expiry Date12/02/2015 | Notice Type |
To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.
| Document Type | Date | Description | File Size | Drawing/Rev Number | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Forms | |||||
| Application Document | 14/01/2015 | Site notice | (120kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/01/2015 | info map | (209kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/01/2015 | neighbour map | (272kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/01/2015 | neighbour consult | (8kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/01/2015 | property history | (15kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/01/2015 | checklist/cons/publcity | (196kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/01/2015 | app form | (65kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Reports – Miscellaneous | 14/01/2015 | Landscape & visual assessment pt 2 | (2908kb) | - | |
| Reports – Miscellaneous | 14/01/2015 | Landscape and visual assessment pt 1 | (3896kb) | - | |
| Reports – Miscellaneous | 14/01/2015 | Extended phase 1 habitat survey & bat survey | (1113kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 14/01/2015 | Planning statement | (4171kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 14/01/2015 | Design and access statement | (568kb) | - | |
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout | 14/01/2015 | 100A proposed site plan | (700kb) | - | |
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout | 14/01/2015 | 10A existing site plan | (569kb) | - | |
| Site Location Plan | 14/01/2015 | 001A location | (157kb) | - | |
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 119B proposed site elevations 3 of 3 | (533kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 118A proposed elevations 2 of 3 | (407kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 117A proposed elevations s1 of 3 | (678kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 121A existing site elevations 2 of 2 | (283kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 120A existing site elevations 1 of 2 | (644kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 015A existing stables 4 plans and elevations | (177kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 014A existing stables 3 plans/elevations | (181kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 013A existing stable 2 plans/elevations | (185kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 012A existing stable 1 plans/elevations | (176kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 011A existing farmhouse plans/elevations | (184kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 122A conversion of existing building to stabling | (189kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 111A proposed first & second floor plans | (203kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/01/2015 | 110A proposed ground floor | (348kb) | - | |
| Plans – Details | 14/01/2015 | 021A permitted development extensions to existing dwelling | (312kb) | - | |
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response | 05/03/2015 | Ecology Officer - 05-03-15 | (25kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 30/01/2015 | Parish 29/01/15 | (145kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 26/01/2015 | Severn Trent Water 21/1/15 | (16kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 17/02/2015 | Landscape 16/02/15 | (26kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 27/01/2015 | OCC Highwasy 27/01/15 | (33kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 14/01/2015 | Ecology 6/1/15 | (11kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 05/03/2015 | Ecology Officer - 05-03-15 | (24kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments | 12/02/2015 | Sabin W, 12/02/15 | (31kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 26/02/2015 | John Wass - 26.02.2015 | (15kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 02/02/2015 | Butt R 31/01/15 | (32kb) | - | |
| Application Forms | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Document (120kb) - Site notice | |||||
| Application Document (209kb) - info map | |||||
| Application Document (272kb) - neighbour map | |||||
| Application Document (8kb) - neighbour consult | |||||
| Application Document (15kb) - property history | |||||
| Application Document (196kb) - checklist/cons/publcity | |||||
| Application Document (65kb) - app form | |||||
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Reports – Miscellaneous (2908kb) - Landscape & visual assessment pt 2 | |||||
| Reports – Miscellaneous (3896kb) - Landscape and visual assessment pt 1 | |||||
| Reports – Miscellaneous (1113kb) - Extended phase 1 habitat survey & bat survey | |||||
| Supporting Documents (4171kb) - Planning statement | |||||
| Supporting Documents (568kb) - Design and access statement | |||||
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (700kb) - 100A proposed site plan | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (569kb) - 10A existing site plan | |||||
| Site Location Plan (157kb) - 001A location | |||||
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (533kb) - 119B proposed site elevations 3 of 3 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (407kb) - 118A proposed elevations 2 of 3 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (678kb) - 117A proposed elevations s1 of 3 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (283kb) - 121A existing site elevations 2 of 2 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (644kb) - 120A existing site elevations 1 of 2 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (177kb) - 015A existing stables 4 plans and elevations | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (181kb) - 014A existing stables 3 plans/elevations | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (185kb) - 013A existing stable 2 plans/elevations | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (176kb) - 012A existing stable 1 plans/elevations | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (184kb) - 011A existing farmhouse plans/elevations | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (189kb) - 122A conversion of existing building to stabling | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (203kb) - 111A proposed first & second floor plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (348kb) - 110A proposed ground floor | |||||
| Plans – Details (312kb) - 021A permitted development extensions to existing dwelling | |||||
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response (25kb) - Ecology Officer - 05-03-15 | |||||
| Consultation Response (145kb) - Parish 29/01/15 | |||||
| Consultation Response (16kb) - Severn Trent Water 21/1/15 | |||||
| Consultation Response (26kb) - Landscape 16/02/15 | |||||
| Consultation Response (33kb) - OCC Highwasy 27/01/15 | |||||
| Consultation Response (11kb) - Ecology 6/1/15 | |||||
| Consultation Response (24kb) - Ecology Officer - 05-03-15 | |||||
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments (31kb) - Sabin W, 12/02/15 | |||||
| Public Comments (15kb) - John Wass - 26.02.2015 | |||||
| Public Comments (32kb) - Butt R 31/01/15 |
| Addresses |
|---|
| Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY |
Planning Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Valid Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | Decision Issued Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15/01693/F | 15/09/2015 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping (revised scheme of 14/02157/F) | Application Withdrawn | 25/02/2016 |
| 16/01563/F | 04/08/2016 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping ((revised scheme of 15/01693/F) | Refused | 01/11/2016 |
| 16/00064/SO | 04/08/2016 | Screening Opinion | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Screening Opinion to Application 16/01563/F - Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping (resubmission 15/01693/F) | Screening Opinion not requesting EIA | 25/08/2016 |
| 14/01100/CLUE | 03/07/2014 | Certificate of Lawful Use Existing | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Certificate of Lawful Use Existing - Use of dwelling in breach of Condition 5 (Agricultural Occupancy) CHN600/85 | Permitted | 27/08/2014 |
| 14/00107/SO | 05/01/2015 | Screening Opinion | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Screening Opinion - Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping | Not proceeded with | 12/09/2022 |
| 15/00089/SO | 15/09/2015 | Screening Opinion | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Screening Opinion to 15/01693/F - Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping (revised scheme of 14/02157/F) | Screening Opinion not requesting EIA | 05/10/2015 |
| 14/02157/F | 05/01/2015 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping | Application Withdrawn | 20/04/2015 |
| 18/00616/F | 10/04/2018 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Variation of Condition 2 (Plans) of 16/01563/F and Appeal ref: APP/C3105/W/17/3173098 | Permitted | 10/07/2018 |
| 17/00191/CLUP | 25/01/2017 | Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Certificate of Lawfulness of Proposed Development for extensions and alterations to the existing dwellinghouse and new ancillary building. | Permitted | 22/03/2017 |
| 18/00358/DISC | 03/09/2018 | Discharge Of Conditions | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Discharge of Conditions 3 (dormers), 4 (materials), 5 (stone sample), 6 (doors and windows), 7 (FFLs), 10 (tree survey), 15 (badger check), 16 (Biodiversity enhancement) and 18 (access) of 18/00793/F | Permitted | 16/11/2018 |
| 17/00259/HPA | 25/01/2017 | Householder Prior Approval | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Single storey rear extension - height to eaves 2.4m, length 8m, overall height 3.8m | Prior Approval Not Required | 03/03/2017 |
| 18/00793/F | 09/05/2018 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Variation of Condition 2 (plans) of 16/01563/F (Appeal reference - APP/C3105/W/17/3173098) - minor material amendments involving alterations to the design of the replacement dwelling as well as the construction of a replacement outbuilding | Permitted | 08/08/2018 |
| 18/01167/F | 29/06/2018 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Creation of new driveway and part removal of existing driveway | Permitted | 09/11/2018 |
| 18/00037/SO | 09/05/2018 | Screening Opinion | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Variation of condition 2 (plans) of 16/01563/F (Appeal reference - APP/C3105/W/17/3173098) - minor material amendments involving alterations to the design of the replacement dwelling as well as the construction of a replacement outbuilding | Screening Opinion not requesting EIA | 22/05/2018 |
| 19/01387/F | 19/07/2019 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Variation of Condition 2 (plans) of 16/01563/F - alterations to the design of the replacement dwelling, the erection of a replacement outbuilding, provision of a new 2m high wall and demolition of two bays of a stable building | Permitted | 09/12/2019 |
| 19/02372/DISC | 11/11/2019 | Discharge Of Conditions | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower OX15 5RY | Discharge of Condition 8 (hard and soft landscape works) of 19/01387/F | Permitted | 29/01/2020 |
| 20/01086/F | 05/05/2020 | Full Development | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower OX15 5RY | Alterations and conversion of existing stable building to provide a gym and swimming pool and change of use of land to amenity land, providing tennis court associated with dwellinghouse replacing existing manège | Permitted | 30/06/2020 |
| 20/02176/DISC | 11/08/2020 | Discharge Of Conditions | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower OX15 5RY | Discharge of Condition 9 (tree pits) of 19/01387/F | Permitted | 12/10/2020 |
| 22/00919/EL | 28/03/2022 | Electricity Notification | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Upgrading 4.6 kilometers of high voltage overhead line from single phase (2 wire) to three phase (3 wire). | Observations | 09/05/2022 |
| 22/03135/F | 17/10/2022 | Full Development | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | RETROSPECTIVE - Formation of an external swimming pool and erection of two associated plant outbuildings and associated landscaping works | Permitted | 14/02/2023 |
| 23/00727/F | 17/03/2023 | Full Development | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Change of use of land to amenity land associated with the use of the dwelling house, with associated treescape, arboreal trail and play equipment, together with the provision of a bocce court within the residential curtilage | Permitted | 12/05/2023 |
| 23/01542/EL | 07/06/2023 | Electricity Notification | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | (Muddle Farm Barn Sibford Gower - REF:1581U) Upgrade 4,600 metres of existing overhead line by adding a third wire and Replace existing poles on the current overhead line where required | No Further Action | 07/06/2023 |
| 24/01201/DISC | 01/05/2024 | Discharge Of Conditions | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Oxfordshire OX15 5RY | Discharge of Condition 3 (Landscaping Scheme) of 23/00727/F | Permitted | 21/06/2024 |
| 24/02021/CLUP | 03/09/2024 | Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower OX15 5RY | Certificate of Lawfulness of Proposed Development for the construction of compost bays | Application Withdrawn | 29/10/2024 |
| 24/03026/F | 11/11/2024 | Full Development | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Oxfordshire OX15 5RY | RETROSPECTIVE - construction of compost bays | ||
Appeal Applications | ||||||
| Appeal number | Appeal Start Date | Appeal Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17/00020/REFAPP | 04/05/2017 | Appeal against Refusal | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Demolition of an existing dwelling and a range of large scale equestrian buildings and the erection of a replacement dwelling including associated works and landscaping ((revised scheme of 15/01693/F) | Appeal Allowed | |
Building Control Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Received Date | Validated Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18/00957/DOMFP | 24/08/2018 | 06/09/2018 | Full Plans | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Building of a replacement dwelling and outbuilding | |
| CP/OFTEC/00129/2017 | 14/09/2017 | 14/09/2017 | Oil Firing Technical Association | Muddle Barn Farm Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Install an oil storage tank | |
| 23/27709/CP | 19/02/2023 | 26/01/2023 | Competent Persons Scheme | Sibford Park Colony Road Sibford Gower Banbury OX15 5RY | Install one or more new circuits. | |