Track this application
| Application Number 20/02669/F |
Application Type Full Development |
| Status Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) |
Decision Level Delegated |
| Location Moorlands Farm
Murcott
Kidlington
OX5 2RE |
|
| Proposal Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings (resubmission of 20/01442/F) |
|
| Parish Fencott And Murcott |
Ward Launton And Otmoor |
| Received Date 28/09/2020 |
Valid Date 19/10/2020 |
| Weekly List Date 20/10/2020 |
Comments Due Date 17/11/2020 |
| Target Decision Date 14/12/2020 |
Committee Date |
| Decision Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) |
Decision Issued Date 18/01/2021 |
| Appeal Received Date 06/04/2021 |
Appeal Start Date |
| Appeal Decision Appeal Dismissed |
Appeal Decision Date 15/07/2021 |
| Applicant Mr B Franklin |
| Applicant's Address Moorlands Farm
Murcott
OX5 2RE |
|
Agent
Barry Waine Planning
|
|
Agents's Address
Mr Barry Waine
Sunnyside Cottage
The Green
Wootton
Northampton
NN4 6LF
|
Written comments are publicly available and cannot be treated as confidential. Please refer to our Comment on a Planning Application page for further information. To view representations received please refer to the documents tab.
Neighbour List
| Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AddressDering Cottage Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received03/11/2020 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date03/11/2020 |
| AddressDering Cottage Murcott OX5 2RE | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| AddressMoorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
Consultee List
| Name | Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NameBuilding Control (CDC) - | AddressBuilding Control Cherwell District Council 39 Castle Quay Banbury OX16 5FD | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received06/11/2020 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameEcology (CDC) - | AddressCherwell District Council 39 Castle Quay Banbury OX16 5FD | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameEnvironmental Health (CDC) - | AddressEnvironmental Health Cherwell District Council 39 Castle Quay Banbury OX16 5FD | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received09/11/2020 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameHighways Local Authority OCC - | AddressOxfordshire County Council County Hall, New Road, Oxford, Oxfordshire, OX1 1ND | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received11/11/2020 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameThames Water - Mr Ndoli Bokuli | AddressMr Ndoli Bokuli Development Planning Asset Investment Unit Maple Lodge Denham Way Rickmansworth WD3 9SQ | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received19/11/2020 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameClerk to Fencott And Murcott PC - Ms Bustin | Address11 Otmoor View Merton Bicester Oxon OX25 2NL | Consult Date21/10/2020 | Reply Due11/11/2020 | Reply Received | TypeStandard Consultee |
| Description | Display Date | Expiry Date | Notice Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| DescriptionSite Notice | Display Date27/10/2020 | Expiry Date17/11/2020 | Notice Type |
To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.
| Document Type | Date | Description | File Size | Drawing/Rev Number | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Forms | |||||
| Application Documents | 29/09/2020 | app form | (117kb) | - | |
| Application Documents | 29/09/2020 | cover letter | (349kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | Protected Species Survey Report | (1077kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | Design And Access Statement | (2460kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | planning report 1 | (4104kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | planning report 2 | (6619kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | planning report 3 | (10300kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | planning Report 4 | (3180kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | planning report 5 | (3979kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 29/09/2020 | Planning Report 6 | (7230kb) | - | |
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans - Site | 29/09/2020 | Location Plan | (1439kb) | SLP1 - | |
| Plans - Site | 29/09/2020 | Site layout | (6864kb) | 604 05 - | |
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans - Proposed | 29/09/2020 | Aerial render | (8452kb) | 604 07 - | |
| Plans - Proposed | 29/09/2020 | Elevations Plot one | (10033kb) | 604 11 - | |
| Plans - Proposed | 29/09/2020 | Elevations Plot three | (9889kb) | 604 15 - | |
| Plans - Proposed | 29/09/2020 | Floor plans Plot one | (6512kb) | 604 10 - | |
| Plans - Proposed | 29/09/2020 | Floor plans Plot two | (6201kb) | 604 12 - | |
| Plans - Proposed | 29/09/2020 | Floor plans Plot three | (6637kb) | 604 14 - | |
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response | 06/11/2020 | Building Control | (73kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 09/11/2020 | Environmental Protection | (16kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 11/11/2020 | OCC Highways | (18kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 19/11/2020 | Thames Water | (10kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments | 03/11/2020 | Dering Cottage | (80kb) | - | |
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report | 18/01/2021 | Delegated Officer Report | (216kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents | 01/06/2021 | Planning Inspectorate advising that the appeal relates to application reference 20/02669/F not 20/01442/F | (117kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 01/06/2021 | PINS appeal start letter | (40kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 01/06/2021 | Appellant statement of case 2 | (5290kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 01/06/2021 | Appellant statement of case 3 | (2612kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 01/06/2021 | Appellant statement of case 4 | (2627kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 01/06/2021 | For all document relating to the appeal, please see appeal record 21/00013/REF | (51kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 15/07/2021 | PINS notification of appeal decision | (34kb) | - | |
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Appeal Decision | 01/06/2021 | Appellant statement of case 1 | (4803kb) | - | |
| Appeal Decision | 15/07/2021 | Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed | (105kb) | - | |
| Decision | 18/01/2021 | Decision Notice | (219kb) | - | |
| Application Forms | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Documents (117kb) - app form | |||||
| Application Documents (349kb) - cover letter | |||||
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Supporting Documents (1077kb) - Protected Species Survey Report | |||||
| Supporting Documents (2460kb) - Design And Access Statement | |||||
| Supporting Documents (4104kb) - planning report 1 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (6619kb) - planning report 2 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (10300kb) - planning report 3 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (3180kb) - planning Report 4 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (3979kb) - planning report 5 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (7230kb) - Planning Report 6 | |||||
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans - Site (1439kb) SLP1 - Location Plan | |||||
| Plans - Site (6864kb) 604 05 - Site layout | |||||
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans - Proposed (8452kb) 604 07 - Aerial render | |||||
| Plans - Proposed (10033kb) 604 11 - Elevations Plot one | |||||
| Plans - Proposed (9889kb) 604 15 - Elevations Plot three | |||||
| Plans - Proposed (6512kb) 604 10 - Floor plans Plot one | |||||
| Plans - Proposed (6201kb) 604 12 - Floor plans Plot two | |||||
| Plans - Proposed (6637kb) 604 14 - Floor plans Plot three | |||||
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response (73kb) - Building Control | |||||
| Consultation Response (16kb) - Environmental Protection | |||||
| Consultation Response (18kb) - OCC Highways | |||||
| Consultation Response (10kb) - Thames Water | |||||
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments (80kb) - Dering Cottage | |||||
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report (216kb) - Delegated Officer Report | |||||
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents (117kb) - Planning Inspectorate advising that the appeal relates to application reference 20/02669/F not 20/01442/F | |||||
| Appeal Documents (40kb) - PINS appeal start letter | |||||
| Appeal Documents (5290kb) - Appellant statement of case 2 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (2612kb) - Appellant statement of case 3 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (2627kb) - Appellant statement of case 4 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (51kb) - For all document relating to the appeal, please see appeal record 21/00013/REF | |||||
| Appeal Documents (34kb) - PINS notification of appeal decision | |||||
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Appeal Decision (4803kb) - Appellant statement of case 1 | |||||
| Appeal Decision (105kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed | |||||
| Decision (219kb) - Decision Notice |
| Addresses |
|---|
| Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott OX5 2RE |
Planning Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Valid Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | Decision Issued Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 96/00972/F | 27/06/1996 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE | Dutch barn. | Permitted | 12/08/1996 |
| 98/01954/F | 01/02/1999 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE | Steel portal frame building and form new vehicular access | Permitted | 10/03/1999 |
| 01/01734/AGN | 20/08/2001 | Agricultural Notification | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE | Proposed Barn for general Agricultural use | Application Withdrawn | 14/09/2001 |
| 01/01924/F | 17/09/2001 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE | Proposed Barn for general agricultural use (storage of machinery, produce and animals) | Permitted | 12/11/2001 |
| 10/00747/F | 14/05/2010 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE | Change of use of barn with extension to provide indoor equestrian school. | Refused | 09/07/2010 |
| 10/00027/F | 22/02/2010 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE | Change of use of barn with extension to provide indoor equestrian school. | Application Withdrawn | 13/04/2010 |
| 13/00373/F | 14/03/2013 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Erection of two 20ft x 70ft bays adjoining an existing farm building on the western elevation together with the erection of a 35ft x 60ft lean-to on the southern elevation | Refused | 14/05/2013 |
| 14/01979/F | 23/07/2015 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Change of use of existing agricultural barn to equine and lean-to extension to include 10 stables, store room and tack room and change of use of land to equine | Permitted | 02/10/2015 |
| 15/00104/CLUP | 22/01/2015 | Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed for change of use of agricultural buildings to dwellings | Permitted | 18/03/2015 |
| 15/00073/SO | 23/07/2015 | Screening Opinion | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Screening opinion to:- 14/01979/F - Change of use of existing agricultural barn to equine and lean-to extension to include 10 stables, store room and tack room and change of use of land to equine | Screening Opinion not requesting EIA | 25/09/2015 |
| 14/01905/PAMB | 13/11/2014 | Prior Approval from Agriculture to Dwellings | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Prior Approval - Change of use of 3 agricultural buildings to 3 dwellings | Prior Approval Refused | 08/01/2015 |
| 16/01023/OUT | 17/06/2016 | Outline Application | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 5 No dwellings | Application Withdrawn | 04/08/2016 |
| 16/01880/OUT | 12/10/2016 | Outline Application | Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Outline - Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 3 dwellings (Resubmission of 16/01023/OUT). | Refused | 19/12/2016 |
| 18/01649/F | 28/09/2018 | Full Development | Land OS Parcel 8751 South West Of Moorlands Farm Murcott | Change of Use of land for the siting of a mobile home (log cabin) | Application Withdrawn | 20/11/2018 |
| 17/01177/OUT | 06/06/2017 | Outline Application | Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 3 dwellings | Refused | 01/08/2017 |
| 17/00597/DISC | 03/01/2018 | Discharge Of Conditions | Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Discharge of Conditions 4 (flood resilient construction method), 5 (external walls and roofs materials and finishes), 6 (turning areas), 7 (parking provision), 8 (manure and soiled beddings storage and disposal scheme) and 13 (ecological report) of 14/01979/F | Permitted | 16/02/2018 |
| 18/01312/F | 09/08/2018 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Conversion of barns to 3 No dwellings | Refused | 04/10/2018 |
| 19/00758/CLUE | 24/04/2019 | Certificate of Lawful Use Existing | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Certificate of Lawfulness of Existing Development to determine the commencement of the development subject of 14/01905/PAMB and deemed lawful under 15/00104/CLUP | Permitted | 19/06/2019 |
| 19/00464/F | 14/03/2019 | Full Development | Land OS Parcel 8751 South West Of Moorlands Farm Murcott | Change of use of land for the siting of a mobile home (log cabin) | Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) | 09/05/2019 |
| 20/01442/F | 12/06/2020 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott OX5 2RE | Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings | Refused | 07/08/2020 |
| 20/01693/F | 26/06/2020 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Change of use of land for the siting of a mobile home (log cabin) | Refused | 26/04/2021 |
| 20/02669/F | 19/10/2020 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings (resubmission of 20/01442/F) | Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) | 18/01/2021 |
| 23/00485/F | 07/03/2023 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott OX5 2RE | Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings and access road. | Refused | 19/09/2023 |
| 24/01008/F | 15/04/2024 | Full Development | Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE | Removal of Condition 8 (occupancy) of CHS.602.87 - The agricultural occupancy condition has outlived its usefulness | Permitted | 28/06/2024 |
| 24/02346/Q56 | 29/08/2024 | Agricultural to Residential (C3) | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Conversion and partial demolition of barns to provide 9 residential dwellings and associated curtilages | Refused | 13/12/2024 |
| 24/03430/Q56 | 30/12/2024 | Agricultural to Residential (C3) | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Conversion and partial demolition of barns to 8 dwellings with associated curtilages | Permitted | 24/02/2025 |
Appeal Applications | ||||||
| Appeal number | Appeal Start Date | Appeal Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11/00002/REFAPP | 21/01/2011 | Appeal against Refusal | Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE | Change of use of barn with extension to provide indoor equestrian school. | Appeal Dismissed | |
| 21/00013/REF | 06/04/2021 | Appeal against Refusal | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings (resubmission of 20/01442/F) | Appeal Dismissed | |
Building Control Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Received Date | Validated Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CP/FENSA/01674/2006 | 04/10/2006 | 04/10/2006 | Window replacement schemes | Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE | Replacement doors/windows | |
| 17/01320/OTHFPD | 14/11/2017 | 16/11/2017 | Full Plans (Domestic/Estimated Cost) | Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE | Conversion of three agricultural buildings into residential dwellings | |