Menu

Planning register

Planning Appeal - 21/00013/REF

Skip to tab headings. Skip to tab content.


Back to results New search


Reference Number
21/00013/REF
 Planning Inspectorate Reference
APP/C3105/W/21/3270091
Location
Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE
Proposal
Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings (resubmission of 20/01442/F)
Status
Appeal Determined
 Parish
Fencott And Murcott
 Ward
Launton And Otmoor
Start Date
06/04/2021
 Comments to PINS Due
15/07/2021
 Appeal Procedure
Planning Case Officer
Matthew Chadwick
 Phone
01295 753754
Appeals Case Officer
Matthew Swinford
 Email
Phone
Venue (if applicable)
Decision
Appeal Dismissed
 Decision Date
15/07/2021

To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.

Document Type Date Description File Size Drawing/Rev Number
Appeal Documents
Appellants Evidence 06/04/2021 Appellant statement of case (15336kb) -
Appellants Evidence 27/05/2021 Appellants final comments (146kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/05/2021 LPA Statement of case (197kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/05/2021 LPA Statement of case Appendix A (6776kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/05/2021 LPA Statement of case Appendix B (808kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/05/2021 LPA Statement of case Appendix C (3202kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/05/2021 LPA Statement of case Appendix D (1177kb) -
Forms and Certs 06/04/2021 Appellant appeal form (2544kb) -
Forms and Certs 13/04/2021 LPA Questionnaire (111kb) -
Miscellaneous 06/04/2021 PINS notification of appeal start (40kb) -
Miscellaneous 01/06/2021 PINS advising regarding application reference relating to the appeal (118kb) -
Miscellaneous 01/06/2021 Appeal notification advising application reference change for appeal (189kb) -
Miscellaneous 15/07/2021 PINS notification of appeal decision (34kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Appeal Notification Letter (190kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Appeal Notification List and deadline for comments (46kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Neighbour list and comments (103kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Consultee list and responses (239kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Local Plan 2011-2031 - PSD1 BSC1 ESD1_10_13_14_15 VIL VIL3 (825kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 H18 (29kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Saved Policies 1996 (43kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Saved Policies Local Plan 2011-2031 (571kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Officer report (99kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Site Notice (109kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Constraints Map (209kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Note regarding question 19a (50kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Note regarding question 19b (45kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 13/04/2021 Relevant Planning History taken from officer report (122kb) -
Third Party Representations 13/05/2021 Third party reps - Dering Cottage (56kb) -
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision 15/07/2021 Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed (105kb) -
Appeal Documents
Appellants Evidence (15336kb) - Appellant statement of case
Appellants Evidence (146kb) - Appellants final comments
Council’s Evidence (197kb) - LPA Statement of case
Council’s Evidence (6776kb) - LPA Statement of case Appendix A
Council’s Evidence (808kb) - LPA Statement of case Appendix B
Council’s Evidence (3202kb) - LPA Statement of case Appendix C
Council’s Evidence (1177kb) - LPA Statement of case Appendix D
Forms and Certs (2544kb) - Appellant appeal form
Forms and Certs (111kb) - LPA Questionnaire
Miscellaneous (40kb) - PINS notification of appeal start
Miscellaneous (118kb) - PINS advising regarding application reference relating to the appeal
Miscellaneous (189kb) - Appeal notification advising application reference change for appeal
Miscellaneous (34kb) - PINS notification of appeal decision
Questionnaire Documents (190kb) - Appeal Notification Letter
Questionnaire Documents (46kb) - Appeal Notification List and deadline for comments
Questionnaire Documents (103kb) - Neighbour list and comments
Questionnaire Documents (239kb) - Consultee list and responses
Questionnaire Documents (825kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - PSD1 BSC1 ESD1_10_13_14_15 VIL VIL3
Questionnaire Documents (29kb) - Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 H18
Questionnaire Documents (43kb) - Saved Policies 1996
Questionnaire Documents (571kb) - Saved Policies Local Plan 2011-2031
Questionnaire Documents (99kb) - Officer report
Questionnaire Documents (109kb) - Site Notice
Questionnaire Documents (209kb) - Constraints Map
Questionnaire Documents (50kb) - Note regarding question 19a
Questionnaire Documents (45kb) - Note regarding question 19b
Questionnaire Documents (122kb) - Relevant Planning History taken from officer report
Third Party Representations (56kb) - Third party reps - Dering Cottage
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision (105kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed

Planning Applications

Application number Valid Date Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Issued Date
96/00972/F 27/06/1996 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE Dutch barn. Permitted 12/08/1996
98/01954/F 01/02/1999 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE Steel portal frame building and form new vehicular access Permitted 10/03/1999
01/01734/AGN 20/08/2001 Agricultural Notification Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE Proposed Barn for general Agricultural use Application Withdrawn 14/09/2001
01/01924/F 17/09/2001 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington Oxon OX5 2RE Proposed Barn for general agricultural use (storage of machinery, produce and animals) Permitted 12/11/2001
10/00747/F 14/05/2010 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE Change of use of barn with extension to provide indoor equestrian school. Refused 09/07/2010
10/00027/F 22/02/2010 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE Change of use of barn with extension to provide indoor equestrian school. Application Withdrawn 13/04/2010
13/00373/F 14/03/2013 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Erection of two 20ft x 70ft bays adjoining an existing farm building on the western elevation together with the erection of a 35ft x 60ft lean-to on the southern elevation Refused 14/05/2013
14/01979/F 23/07/2015 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Change of use of existing agricultural barn to equine and lean-to extension to include 10 stables, store room and tack room and change of use of land to equine Permitted 02/10/2015
15/00104/CLUP 22/01/2015 Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed for change of use of agricultural buildings to dwellings Permitted 18/03/2015
15/00073/SO 23/07/2015 Screening Opinion Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Screening opinion to:- 14/01979/F - Change of use of existing agricultural barn to equine and lean-to extension to include 10 stables, store room and tack room and change of use of land to equine Screening Opinion not requesting EIA 25/09/2015
14/01905/PAMB 13/11/2014 Prior Approval from Agriculture to Dwellings Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Prior Approval - Change of use of 3 agricultural buildings to 3 dwellings Prior Approval Refused 08/01/2015
16/01023/OUT 17/06/2016 Outline Application Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 5 No dwellings Application Withdrawn 04/08/2016
16/01880/OUT 12/10/2016 Outline Application Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Outline - Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 3 dwellings (Resubmission of 16/01023/OUT). Refused 19/12/2016
18/01649/F 28/09/2018 Full Development Land OS Parcel 8751 South West Of Moorlands Farm Murcott Change of Use of land for the siting of a mobile home (log cabin) Application Withdrawn 20/11/2018
17/01177/OUT 06/06/2017 Outline Application Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 3 dwellings Refused 01/08/2017
17/00597/DISC 03/01/2018 Discharge Of Conditions Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Discharge of Conditions 4 (flood resilient construction method), 5 (external walls and roofs materials and finishes), 6 (turning areas), 7 (parking provision), 8 (manure and soiled beddings storage and disposal scheme) and 13 (ecological report) of 14/01979/F Permitted 16/02/2018
18/01312/F 09/08/2018 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Conversion of barns to 3 No dwellings Refused 04/10/2018
19/00758/CLUE 24/04/2019 Certificate of Lawful Use Existing Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Certificate of Lawfulness of Existing Development to determine the commencement of the development subject of 14/01905/PAMB and deemed lawful under 15/00104/CLUP Permitted 19/06/2019
19/00464/F 14/03/2019 Full Development Land OS Parcel 8751 South West Of Moorlands Farm Murcott Change of use of land for the siting of a mobile home (log cabin) Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) 09/05/2019
20/01442/F 12/06/2020 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott OX5 2RE Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings Refused 07/08/2020
20/01693/F 26/06/2020 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Change of use of land for the siting of a mobile home (log cabin) Refused 26/04/2021
20/02669/F 19/10/2020 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings (resubmission of 20/01442/F) Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) 18/01/2021
23/00485/F 07/03/2023 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott OX5 2RE Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings and access road. Refused 19/09/2023
24/01008/F 15/04/2024 Full Development Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE Removal of Condition 8 (occupancy) of CHS.602.87 - The agricultural occupancy condition has outlived its usefulness Permitted 28/06/2024
24/02346/Q56 29/08/2024 Agricultural to Residential (C3) Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Conversion and partial demolition of barns to provide 9 residential dwellings and associated curtilages Refused 13/12/2024
24/03430/Q56 30/12/2024 Agricultural to Residential (C3) Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Conversion and partial demolition of barns to 8 dwellings with associated curtilages Permitted 24/02/2025

Appeal Applications

Appeal number Appeal Start Date Appeal Type Location Proposal Decision
11/00002/REFAPP 21/01/2011 Appeal against Refusal Moorlands Farm Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE Change of use of barn with extension to provide indoor equestrian school. Appeal Dismissed
21/00013/REF 06/04/2021 Appeal against Refusal Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Demolition of existing agricultural buildings and erection of three dwellings (resubmission of 20/01442/F) Appeal Dismissed

Building Control Applications

Application number Received Date Validated Date Application Type Location Proposal
CP/FENSA/01674/2006 04/10/2006 04/10/2006 Window replacement schemes Moorlands Farm Street Through Murcott Village Murcott Oxfordshire OX5 2RE Replacement doors/windows
17/01320/OTHFPD 14/11/2017 16/11/2017 Full Plans (Domestic/Estimated Cost) Moorlands Farm Murcott Kidlington OX5 2RE Conversion of three agricultural buildings into residential dwellings

Back to top.