Track this application
| Application Number 18/01926/F |
Application Type Full Development |
| Status Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) |
Decision Level Delegated |
| Case Officer Michael Sackey |
|
| Location Greene House
Brill Road
Horton Cum Studley
Oxford
OX33 1BZ |
|
| Proposal Erection of timber garage and workshop (alternative scheme to development approved under application ref. 17/01894/f, comprising higher ridge line, increased length of building and eaves height to approved and insertion of 4no rooflights to east-facing roof elevation) (existing unauthorised) |
|
| Parish Horton Cum Studley |
Ward Launton And Otmoor |
| Received Date 07/11/2018 |
Valid Date 07/11/2018 |
| Weekly List Date |
Comments Due Date 20/12/2018 |
| Target Decision Date 21/01/2019 |
Committee Date |
| Decision Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) |
Decision Issued Date 21/01/2019 |
| Appeal Received Date 05/02/2019 |
Appeal Start Date |
| Appeal Decision Appeal Dismissed |
Appeal Decision Date 06/06/2019 |
| Applicant Mr Peter Greenslade |
| Applicant's Address Greene House
Brill Road
Horton Cum Studley
Oxford
OX33 1BZ |
|
Agent
JPPC
|
|
Agents's Address
Mr Simon Sharp
Bagley Croft
Hinksey Hill
Oxford
OX1 5BD
United Kingdom
|
Written comments are publicly available and cannot be treated as confidential. Please refer to our Comment on a Planning Application page for further information. To view representations received please refer to the documents tab.
Neighbour List
| Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AddressStudley Barn Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BP | Consult Date20/11/2018 | Reply Due11/12/2018 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| AddressThe Paddocks Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Consult Date20/11/2018 | Reply Due11/12/2018 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| AddressManor Cottage Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BU | Consult Date20/11/2018 | Reply Due11/12/2018 | Reply Received26/11/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date26/11/2018 |
Consultee List
| Name | Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NameHorton Cum Studley Parish Council | AddressKimber House Horton Hill HORTON-CUM-STUDLEY OX33 1AY | Consult Date20/11/2018 | Reply Due11/12/2018 | Reply Received | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameLocal Highways Authority OCC | Address | Consult Date20/11/2018 | Reply Due11/12/2018 | Reply Received29/11/2018 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| Description | Display Date | Expiry Date | Notice Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| DescriptionSite Notice General | Display Date26/11/2018 | Expiry Date20/12/2018 | Notice Type |
To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.
| Document Type | Date | Description | File Size | Drawing/Rev Number | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Forms | |||||
| Application Document | 20/11/2018 | Publicity | (16kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/11/2018 | app form | (69kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/11/2018 | Neighbour Map | (52kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/11/2018 | Neighbour Consults | (52kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/11/2018 | Property History | (75kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/11/2018 | Info Map (Arc) | (124kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 14/11/2018 | Checklist | (130kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 06/02/2019 | site visit | (22kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Photographs | 21/01/2019 | Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | (5306kb) | - | |
| Photographs | 21/01/2019 | Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | (5144kb) | - | |
| Photographs | 21/01/2019 | Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | (4812kb) | - | |
| Photographs | 21/01/2019 | Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | (5198kb) | - | |
| Photographs | 21/01/2019 | Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | (4533kb) | - | |
| Photographs | 21/01/2019 | Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | (4002kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 14/11/2018 | planning statement | (675kb) | - | |
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout | 14/11/2018 | block plan | (41kb) | - | |
| Site Location Plan | 14/11/2018 | location plan | (82kb) | - | |
| Existing Plans | |||||
| Plans – Sections/Surveys | 22/01/2019 | cross sections & levels | (35kb) | - | |
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 14/11/2018 | plans & elevations | (83kb) | - | |
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response | 30/11/2018 | OCC Highways 29.11.18 | (16kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments | 26/11/2018 | Raleigh, D 22.11.18 | (13kb) | - | |
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report | 30/01/2019 | 21.01.19 | (252kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents | 09/04/2019 | Saved Policies | (571kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 09/04/2019 | Saved Policies | (43kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 09/04/2019 | Consult list and responses | (330kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 09/04/2019 | Neighbour list and responses | (217kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 09/04/2019 | Appeal letter | (402kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 09/04/2019 | Planning letter | (580kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 09/04/2019 | PINS notice of appeal start 02.04.19 | (39kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 06/06/2019 | PINS notice of appeal decision 06/06/19 | (34kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 09/04/2019 | Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 14 ESD15 | (752kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 09/04/2019 | Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 14 ESD15 | (752kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 09/04/2019 | Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 | (26kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 09/04/2019 | Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 | (26kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 04/04/2019 | Appellant statement of case | (4571kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 04/04/2019 | Appellant statement of case | (4571kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 04/04/2019 | Appellant Appeal form | (92kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 09/04/2019 | LPA Questionnaire | (97kb) | - | |
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision | 22/01/2019 | Refusal - 21.01.19 | (2974kb) | - | |
| Decision | 06/06/2019 | Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 06/06/2019 | (118kb) | - | |
| Application Forms | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Document (16kb) - Publicity | |||||
| Application Document (69kb) - app form | |||||
| Application Document (52kb) - Neighbour Map | |||||
| Application Document (52kb) - Neighbour Consults | |||||
| Application Document (75kb) - Property History | |||||
| Application Document (124kb) - Info Map (Arc) | |||||
| Application Document (130kb) - Checklist | |||||
| Application Document (22kb) - site visit | |||||
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Photographs (5306kb) - Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | |||||
| Photographs (5144kb) - Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | |||||
| Photographs (4812kb) - Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | |||||
| Photographs (5198kb) - Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | |||||
| Photographs (4533kb) - Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | |||||
| Photographs (4002kb) - Officer site visit 26.11.2018 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (675kb) - planning statement | |||||
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (41kb) - block plan | |||||
| Site Location Plan (82kb) - location plan | |||||
| Existing Plans | |||||
| Plans – Sections/Surveys (35kb) - cross sections & levels | |||||
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (83kb) - plans & elevations | |||||
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response (16kb) - OCC Highways 29.11.18 | |||||
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments (13kb) - Raleigh, D 22.11.18 | |||||
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report (252kb) - 21.01.19 | |||||
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents (571kb) - Saved Policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (43kb) - Saved Policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (330kb) - Consult list and responses | |||||
| Appeal Documents (217kb) - Neighbour list and responses | |||||
| Appeal Documents (402kb) - Appeal letter | |||||
| Appeal Documents (580kb) - Planning letter | |||||
| Appeal Documents (39kb) - PINS notice of appeal start 02.04.19 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (34kb) - PINS notice of appeal decision 06/06/19 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (752kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 14 ESD15 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (752kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 14 ESD15 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (26kb) - Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (26kb) - Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (4571kb) - Appellant statement of case | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (4571kb) - Appellant statement of case | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (92kb) - Appellant Appeal form | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (97kb) - LPA Questionnaire | |||||
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision (2974kb) - Refusal - 21.01.19 | |||||
| Decision (118kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 06/06/2019 |
| Addresses |
|---|
| Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ |
Planning Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Valid Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | Decision Issued Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 04/00386/F | 16/02/2004 | Full Development | Red Bungalow Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford Oxon | Demolish existing bungalow, garage/workshop and outbuildings. Erection of 1 No. dwelling. | Refused | 13/04/2004 |
| 16/01633/F | 11/08/2016 | Full Development | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Erection of four bay garage with home office and storage | Refused | 01/11/2016 |
| 17/01894/F | 14/09/2017 | Full Development | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Erection of timber garage and workshop | Permitted | 09/11/2017 |
| 18/01926/F | 07/11/2018 | Full Development | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Erection of timber garage and workshop (alternative scheme to development approved under application ref. 17/01894/f, comprising higher ridge line, increased length of building and eaves height to approved and insertion of 4no rooflights to east-facing roof elevation) (existing unauthorised) | Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) | 21/01/2019 |
| 18/00038/NMA | 18/04/2018 | Non Material Amendments | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Addition of 4 No rooflights - proposed as non-material amendment to 17/01894/F | Refused | 14/09/2018 |
| 19/01540/F | 22/08/2019 | Full Development | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Variation of Condition 2 of 17/02894/F - reduce ridge height to 4.0m, installation of 4 rolights, increase depth by 0.16m, increase width by 0.3m and reconfigure doors and windows | Permitted | 12/12/2019 |
| 21/03015/F | 15/11/2021 | Full Development | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley OX33 1BZ | Pond on agricultural land | Permitted | 31/01/2022 |
Appeal Applications | ||||||
| Appeal number | Appeal Start Date | Appeal Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17/00003/REFAPP | 01/02/2017 | Appeal against Refusal | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Erection of four bay garage with home office and storage | Appeal Dismissed | |
| 19/00007/REFAPP | 02/04/2019 | Appeal against Refusal | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Erection of timber garage and workshop (alternative scheme to development approved under application ref. 17/01894/f, comprising higher ridge line, increased length of building and eaves height to approved and insertion of 4no rooflights to east-facing roof elevation) (existing unauthorised) | Appeal Dismissed | |
Building Control Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Received Date | Validated Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 05/01477/DOMFP | 23/12/2005 | 30/12/2005 | Full Plans | Red Bungalow Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford Oxon | Erection of new dwelling - single house (replacement dwelling for existing bungalow) | |
| CP/GASAFE/01681/2014 | 23/08/2013 | 23/08/2013 | Gas Safe | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Installed an Unvented Hot Water Storage Vessel | |
| CP/ELECSA/00697/2015 | 23/08/2013 | 23/08/2013 | Electrical Safety in dwellings | Greene House Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | New Dwelling | |