Track this application
| Application Number 18/01436/F |
Application Type Full Development |
| Status Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) |
Decision Level Delegated |
| Location Land Adjacent And West Of Roba
Camp Road
Upper Heyford |
|
| Proposal Erection of three residential dwellings |
|
| Parish Upper Heyford |
Ward Fringford And Heyfords |
| Received Date 10/08/2018 |
Valid Date 22/08/2018 |
| Weekly List Date |
Comments Due Date 01/10/2018 |
| Target Decision Date 17/10/2018 |
Committee Date |
| Decision Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) |
Decision Issued Date 17/10/2018 |
| Appeal Received Date 21/12/2018 |
Appeal Start Date |
| Appeal Decision Appeal Dismissed |
Appeal Decision Date 06/08/2019 |
| Applicant Sharon Haddy & Mandy Borton |
| Applicant's Address C/O Agent |
|
Agent
Oakwood Planning Limited
|
|
Agents's Address
Jayne Cashmore
Oakwood House
Lavender Hall Lane
Berkswell, Coventry
CV7 7BN
|
Written comments are publicly available and cannot be treated as confidential. Please refer to our Comment on a Planning Application page for further information. To view representations received please refer to the documents tab.
Neighbour List
| Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AddressThe Rickyard Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LH | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received17/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date17/09/2018 |
| AddressWykeham House High Street Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LE | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received14/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date14/09/2018 |
| AddressHillside Cottage High Street Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LE | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received23/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date23/09/2018 |
| AddressHillside Cottage High Street Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LE | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received23/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date23/09/2018 |
| AddressPaddock Cottage Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received17/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date17/09/2018 |
| AddressFoxgloves Somerton Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LB | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received13/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date13/09/2018 |
| Address7 Somerton Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LB | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received17/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date17/09/2018 |
| AddressSnowdrop Lodge Mill Lane Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LH | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received13/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date13/09/2018 |
| Address3 New College Square Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5NG | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received14/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date14/09/2018 |
| Address1 The Three Horseshoes Somerton Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5JU | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received14/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date14/09/2018 |
| AddressHolly Trees Somerton Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LB | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| Address1 The Old Post House Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| Address1 Jalna Lodge Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| Address2 The Old Post House Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| Address2 Jalna Lodge Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received03/10/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date03/10/2018 |
| AddressOrchard Cottage Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received11/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date11/09/2018 |
| AddressPaddock Cottage Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received17/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date17/09/2018 |
| AddressLodge Cottage Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester OX25 5LJ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received17/09/2018 | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date17/09/2018 |
Consultee List
| Name | Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NameConservation (CDC) | Address | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due07/09/2018 | Reply Received19/10/2018 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameEcology (CDC) | Address | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due07/09/2018 | Reply Received20/09/2018 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameLocal Highways Authority OCC | Address | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due07/09/2018 | Reply Received12/09/2018 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameRights Of Way (OCC) | Address | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due14/09/2018 | Reply Received24/08/2018 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameThames Water | AddressDevelopment Planning Asset Investment Unit Maple Lodge Denham Way RICKMANSWORTH WD3 9SQ | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due13/09/2018 | Reply Received | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameUpper Heyford Parish Council | AddressHillside Cottage Upper Heyford BICESTER OX25 5LE | Consult Date23/08/2018 | Reply Due14/09/2018 | Reply Received26/09/2018 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| Description | Display Date | Expiry Date | Notice Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| DescriptionBicester Advertiser | Display Date06/09/2018 | Expiry Date27/09/2018 | Notice Type |
| DescriptionSite Notice General | Display Date10/09/2018 | Expiry Date01/10/2018 | Notice Type |
To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.
| Document Type | Date | Description | File Size | Drawing/Rev Number | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Forms | |||||
| Application Document | 19/10/2018 | (0kb) | - | ||
| Application Document | 23/08/2018 | Publicity | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 22/08/2018 | Neighbour map | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 23/08/2018 | app form | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 23/08/2018 | Neighbour list | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 23/08/2018 | Checklist | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 21/08/2018 | Info map | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Supporting Documents | 23/08/2018 | Design statement | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 23/08/2018 | Design & Access Statement | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 23/08/2018 | Ecological Appraisal | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 23/08/2018 | Arboricultural report | (0kb) | - | |
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 23/08/2018 | proposed plans drg no 06 | (0kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 23/08/2018 | proposed plans plot 03 drg no 05a | (0kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 23/08/2018 | proposed plans plot 2 drg no 04 | (0kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 23/08/2018 | proposed plans plot 1 drg no 03 | (0kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 23/08/2018 | proposed plans drg no 02 | (0kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 23/08/2018 | Existing plans drg no 01 | (0kb) | - | |
| Plans – Landscape | 23/08/2018 | Tree constraints plan | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response | 26/09/2018 | Upper Heyford PC comments 21/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 17/09/2018 | Mid Cherwell Neighbourhood Forum - 17.09.18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 19/10/2018 | Conservation comments 11/10/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 20/09/2018 | CDC Ecology - 20.09.18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 20/09/2018 | CDC Ecology - 20.09.18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 12/09/2018 | OCC Highways comments 06/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 24/08/2018 | OCC Rights of way - 24.08.18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments | 18/09/2018 | Hiles, M 17/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 18/09/2018 | Hedges, A 14/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 17/09/2018 | Upper Heyford Village Group 14/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 17/09/2018 | Weaver, P 13/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 17/09/2018 | Allen, K 13/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 03/10/2018 | Croft-Pearson, C&E 01/10/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 17/09/2018 | Stewart Lee, W 14/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 17/09/2018 | Maidment-Vint, V 13/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 17/09/2018 | Yorke, K 14/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 17/09/2018 | Van Zwanenberg, S 14/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 14/09/2018 | Alesbury, R 11/09/18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report | 18/10/2018 | 17.10.18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents | 18/01/2019 | PINS notice of appeal start date 18.01.19 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 27/02/2019 | Third party comments - Combined | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Mid-Cherwell Neighbourhood plan 2018-2031 March 2018 Appendices 1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Mid-Cherwell Neighbourhood plan 2018-2031 submission version March 2018 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Press notice | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Upper Heyford Conservation area appraisal map | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Upper Heyford Conservation area appraisal draft | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Saved Policies | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Saved Policies | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Consult list | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Neighbour list | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/01/2019 | Appeal letter | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 06/08/2019 | PINS notification of appeal decision 06.08.19 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence | 08/03/2019 | Appellants final comments - Worrledge Associates | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence | 08/03/2019 | Appellants final comments - Oakwood Planning Limited | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence | 18/01/2019 | Appellant statement of case | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 18/01/2019 | Appellant appeal form | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 22/02/2019 | LPA statement of case Appendix 1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 22/02/2019 | LPA statement of case Appendix 1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 22/02/2019 | LPA statement of case | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 23/01/2019 | Local Plan 1996 H18 C15 C28 C30 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 23/01/2019 | Local Plan 1996 H18 C15 C28 C30 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 23/01/2019 | Local Plan 2011-2031 - PSD1 BSC1 BSC4 ESD10 ESD15 VIL1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 23/01/2019 | Local Plan 2011-2031 - PSD1 BSC1 BSC4 ESD10 ESD15 VIL1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 23/01/2019 | LPA Questionnaire | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 22/02/2019 | LPA statement of case | (0kb) | - | |
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision | 17/10/2018 | 17.10.18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Decision | 06/08/2019 | Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 06.08.19 | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Forms | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Document (0kb) - | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Publicity | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour map | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - app form | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour list | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Checklist | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Info map | |||||
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - Design statement | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - Design & Access Statement | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - Ecological Appraisal | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - Arboricultural report | |||||
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - proposed plans drg no 06 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - proposed plans plot 03 drg no 05a | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - proposed plans plot 2 drg no 04 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - proposed plans plot 1 drg no 03 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - proposed plans drg no 02 | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (0kb) - Existing plans drg no 01 | |||||
| Plans – Landscape (0kb) - Tree constraints plan | |||||
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - Upper Heyford PC comments 21/09/18 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - Mid Cherwell Neighbourhood Forum - 17.09.18 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - Conservation comments 11/10/18 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - CDC Ecology - 20.09.18 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - CDC Ecology - 20.09.18 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - OCC Highways comments 06/09/18 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - OCC Rights of way - 24.08.18 | |||||
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Hiles, M 17/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Hedges, A 14/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Upper Heyford Village Group 14/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Weaver, P 13/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Allen, K 13/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Croft-Pearson, C&E 01/10/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Stewart Lee, W 14/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Maidment-Vint, V 13/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Yorke, K 14/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Van Zwanenberg, S 14/09/18 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Alesbury, R 11/09/18 | |||||
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report (0kb) - 17.10.18 | |||||
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appeal start date 18.01.19 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Third party comments - Combined | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Mid-Cherwell Neighbourhood plan 2018-2031 March 2018 Appendices 1 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Mid-Cherwell Neighbourhood plan 2018-2031 submission version March 2018 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Press notice | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Upper Heyford Conservation area appraisal map | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Upper Heyford Conservation area appraisal draft | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved Policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved Policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Consult list | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Neighbour list | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Appeal letter | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notification of appeal decision 06.08.19 | |||||
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellants final comments - Worrledge Associates | |||||
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellants final comments - Oakwood Planning Limited | |||||
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant statement of case | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Appellant appeal form | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA statement of case Appendix 1 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA statement of case Appendix 1 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA statement of case | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 H18 C15 C28 C30 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 H18 C15 C28 C30 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - PSD1 BSC1 BSC4 ESD10 ESD15 VIL1 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - PSD1 BSC1 BSC4 ESD10 ESD15 VIL1 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Questionnaire | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA statement of case | |||||
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision (0kb) - 17.10.18 | |||||
| Decision (0kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 06.08.19 |
| Addresses |
|---|
| Land Adjacent And West Of Roba Camp Road Upper Heyford |
Planning Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Valid Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | Decision Issued Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 97/01427/OUT | 01/10/1997 | Outline Application | Land Adjacent And West Of Roba (Former P.O.) Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester Oxon | Erection of detached houses and garages. Alteration to access. (OUTLINE) | Refused | 17/11/1997 |
| 97/01428/CAC | 01/10/1997 | Conservation Area | Land Adjacent And West Of Roba (Former P.O.) Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester Oxon | Demolition of existing workshops | Permitted | 17/11/1997 |
| 97/00923/OUT | 20/05/1997 | Outline Application | Land Adjacent And West Of Roba (Former P.O.) Camp Road Upper Heyford Bicester Oxon | Erection of detached houses and garages. Alteration to access (OUTLINE). | Application Withdrawn | 23/06/1997 |
| 18/01436/F | 22/08/2018 | Full Development | Land Adjacent And West Of Roba Camp Road Upper Heyford | Erection of three residential dwellings | Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) | 17/10/2018 |
| 21/03190/F | 16/09/2021 | Full Development | Land North of Camp Road, East of Holly Trees and 1 Jalna Lodge Camp Road Upper Heyford | Erection of dwelling, detached garage, widening of vehicular access and all associated works | Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) | 21/06/2022 |
Appeal Applications | ||||||
| Appeal number | Appeal Start Date | Appeal Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18/00038/REFAPP | 18/01/2019 | Appeal against Refusal | Land Adjacent And West Of Roba Camp Road Upper Heyford | Erection of three residential dwellings | Appeal Dismissed | |
| 22/00034/NON | 21/06/2022 | Appeal against Non-determination | Land North of Camp Road, East of Holly Trees and 1 Jalna Lodge Camp Road Upper Heyford | Erection of dwelling, detached garage, widening of vehicular access and all associated works | Appeal Dismissed | |