Track this application
| Application Number 16/02058/F |
Application Type Full Development |
| Status Application Refused |
Decision Level Delegated |
| Location March House
March Road
Mollington
Banbury
OX17 1BP |
|
| Proposal Erection of replacement garage and garden store with home office over |
|
| Parish Mollington |
Ward Cropredy, Sibfords And Wroxton |
| Received Date 11/10/2016 |
Valid Date 27/10/2016 |
| Weekly List Date |
Comments Due Date 01/12/2016 |
| Target Decision Date 22/12/2016 |
Committee Date |
| Decision Refused |
Decision Issued Date 22/12/2016 |
| Appeal Received Date 03/01/2017 |
Appeal Start Date |
| Appeal Decision Appeal Dismissed |
Appeal Decision Date 28/03/2017 |
| Applicant Mr & Mrs G Finlay |
| Applicant's Address March House
Main Street
Mollington
OX17 1BP |
|
Agent
Mathewson Waters Architects
|
|
Agents's Address
Mr Howard Waters
The Old Surgery
Crowle Road
Lambourn, Hungerford
RG17 8NR
|
Written comments are publicly available and cannot be treated as confidential. Please refer to our Comment on a Planning Application page for further information. To view representations received please refer to the documents tab.
Neighbour List
| Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AddressMarch Hill March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Consult Date03/11/2016 | Reply Due24/11/2016 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| AddressLilac View 2 The Paddocks Mollington Banbury OX17 1BW | Consult Date03/11/2016 | Reply Due24/11/2016 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
| AddressSophena House Main Street Mollington Banbury OX17 1BN | Consult Date03/11/2016 | Reply Due24/11/2016 | Reply Received | Re-Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Date |
Consultee List
| Name | Address | Consult Date | Reply Due | Reply Received | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NameArboriculture (CDC) | Address | Consult Date03/11/2016 | Reply Due17/11/2016 | Reply Received17/11/2016 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameArchaeology (OCC) | Address | Consult Date03/11/2016 | Reply Due24/11/2016 | Reply Received08/11/2016 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameLocal Highways Authority OCC | Address | Consult Date03/11/2016 | Reply Due17/11/2016 | Reply Received29/11/2016 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| NameGinetta Best - Mollington Parish Council | AddressSunnybank Mollington Banbury Oxon OX17 1BD | Consult Date03/11/2016 | Reply Due24/11/2016 | Reply Received22/11/2016 | TypeStandard Consultee |
| Description | Display Date | Expiry Date | Notice Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| DescriptionSite Notice General | Display Date10/11/2016 | Expiry Date01/12/2016 | Notice Type |
| Description | Display Date10/11/2016 | Expiry Date01/12/2016 | Notice Type |
To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.
| Document Type | Date | Description | File Size | Drawing/Rev Number | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Forms | |||||
| Application Document | 03/11/2016 | Publicity | (130kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 28/10/2016 | App form | (56kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 28/10/2016 | Checklist | (112kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 28/10/2016 | Footpath map | (154kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 28/10/2016 | Info map | (92kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 28/10/2016 | Neighbour list | (51kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 28/10/2016 | Neighbour map | (68kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 30/12/2016 | site visit | (22kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Supporting Documents | 28/10/2016 | Arboricultural Survey | (2086kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 28/10/2016 | Arboricultural Impact Assessment | (1726kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 28/10/2016 | Design & Access statement | (1045kb) | - | |
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout | 28/10/2016 | Proposed floor/site plan | (668kb) | - | |
| Site Location Plan | 28/10/2016 | Location & Block Plan | (542kb) | - | |
| Existing Plans | |||||
| Plans – Sections/Surveys | 28/10/2016 | Topographical Survey | (634kb) | - | |
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 28/10/2016 | Additional elevations | (633kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 28/10/2016 | Proposed attic plan | (503kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 28/10/2016 | Proposed elevations | (680kb) | - | |
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations | 28/10/2016 | Proposed elevations | (739kb) | - | |
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response | 07/12/2016 | Arboricultural comments 05/12/16 | (90kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 08/11/2016 | OCC Archaeology - 04.11.16 | (24kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 05/12/2016 | Mollington PC 22-11-16 | (20kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 29/11/2016 | OCC Highways 29/11/16 | (25kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 18/11/2016 | CDC Arboricultural Officer - 17.11.16 | (24kb) | - | |
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report | 22/12/2016 | Case Officers report - 22.12.16 | (213kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | Saved policies | (571kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | Saved policies | (43kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | Mollington Conservation Area | (3312kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | Consultation responses | (372kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | Neighbour list | (42kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | Appeal Notificaiton letter | (240kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | Planning Notificaiton letter | (168kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 02/02/2017 | PINS notice of appeal start date 31/01/17 | (38kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 07/02/2017 | PINS notice of appellants applicaiton for costs | (24kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 02/02/2017 | Local Plan 1996 C28 | (91kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 02/02/2017 | Local Plan 1996 C28 | (91kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 02/02/2017 | Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13 ESD 15 | (332kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 02/02/2017 | Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13 ESD 15 | (332kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 02/02/2017 | LPA Questionnaire | (101kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 02/02/2017 | Appellant appeal form | (93kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 07/02/2017 | LPA response to costs | (206kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 07/02/2017 | LPA response to costs | (206kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 07/02/2017 | Appellant application for costs | (77kb) | - | |
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision | 29/03/2017 | Appeal Costs Decision - Costs Refused 28/03/17 | (118kb) | - | |
| Decision | 29/03/2017 | Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 28/03/17 | (115kb) | - | |
| Decision | 22/12/2016 | Refusal - 22.12.16 | (1708kb) | - | |
| Tree Preservation Orders | 28/10/2016 | TPO No.5/93 | (47kb) | - | |
| Application Forms | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Document (130kb) - Publicity | |||||
| Application Document (56kb) - App form | |||||
| Application Document (112kb) - Checklist | |||||
| Application Document (154kb) - Footpath map | |||||
| Application Document (92kb) - Info map | |||||
| Application Document (51kb) - Neighbour list | |||||
| Application Document (68kb) - Neighbour map | |||||
| Application Document (22kb) - site visit | |||||
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Supporting Documents (2086kb) - Arboricultural Survey | |||||
| Supporting Documents (1726kb) - Arboricultural Impact Assessment | |||||
| Supporting Documents (1045kb) - Design & Access statement | |||||
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (668kb) - Proposed floor/site plan | |||||
| Site Location Plan (542kb) - Location & Block Plan | |||||
| Existing Plans | |||||
| Plans – Sections/Surveys (634kb) - Topographical Survey | |||||
| Proposed Plans | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (633kb) - Additional elevations | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (503kb) - Proposed attic plan | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (680kb) - Proposed elevations | |||||
| Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (739kb) - Proposed elevations | |||||
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response (90kb) - Arboricultural comments 05/12/16 | |||||
| Consultation Response (24kb) - OCC Archaeology - 04.11.16 | |||||
| Consultation Response (20kb) - Mollington PC 22-11-16 | |||||
| Consultation Response (25kb) - OCC Highways 29/11/16 | |||||
| Consultation Response (24kb) - CDC Arboricultural Officer - 17.11.16 | |||||
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report (213kb) - Case Officers report - 22.12.16 | |||||
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents (571kb) - Saved policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (43kb) - Saved policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (3312kb) - Mollington Conservation Area | |||||
| Appeal Documents (372kb) - Consultation responses | |||||
| Appeal Documents (42kb) - Neighbour list | |||||
| Appeal Documents (240kb) - Appeal Notificaiton letter | |||||
| Appeal Documents (168kb) - Planning Notificaiton letter | |||||
| Appeal Documents (38kb) - PINS notice of appeal start date 31/01/17 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (24kb) - PINS notice of appellants applicaiton for costs | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (91kb) - Local Plan 1996 C28 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (91kb) - Local Plan 1996 C28 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (332kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13 ESD 15 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (332kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 13 ESD 15 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (101kb) - LPA Questionnaire | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (93kb) - Appellant appeal form | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (206kb) - LPA response to costs | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (206kb) - LPA response to costs | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (77kb) - Appellant application for costs | |||||
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision (118kb) - Appeal Costs Decision - Costs Refused 28/03/17 | |||||
| Decision (115kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 28/03/17 | |||||
| Decision (1708kb) - Refusal - 22.12.16 | |||||
| Tree Preservation Orders (47kb) - TPO No.5/93 |
| Addresses |
|---|
| March House March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP |
Planning Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Valid Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | Decision Issued Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02/00986/TPO | 03/05/2002 | Works To Tree Preservation Order | March House Mollington Banbury Oxon OX17 1BP | Fell 26 no. Willow trees subject to TPO 5/93 | Permitted | 25/06/2002 |
| 07/02099/F | 29/10/2007 | Full Development | March House Main Street Mollington Banbury Oxfordshire OX17 1BP | Demolition of existing house and garage block and replacement with two storey dwelling with integral garage. Works to trees subject to TPO 5/93 | Permitted | 21/12/2007 |
| 09/01219/TPO | 08/09/2009 | Works To Tree Preservation Order | March House Main Street Mollington Banbury Oxfordshire OX17 1BP | Area G1 Willows-T1, T2 crown lift 4 metres, remove all dead dying and dangerous wood. T3 crown reduce to 12 to 14 metres retaining the shape and habit of the tree species. T4 crown reduce to 8 metres retaining the shape and habit of the tree species. T5 Willow remove to ground level. T7 Willow remove to ground level. Area A3-Remove Beech, Ash and two Conifers as agreed on site. Remainder of trees within A3 to be crown lifted to 3 metres. Undergrowth below power lines to be felled to ground level. Area A1 (tree Nos. refer to Sacha Barnes Arb report) No5, No8 Hawthorns - coppice at 6 to 8 inches. No. 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 Beech tidy stubs, crown thin by 10 to 15 percent. No 16 Beech with cavity to base - remove to ground level - Subject to TPO 5/93 | Permitted | 19/10/2009 |
| 17/00793/F | 10/04/2017 | Full Development | March House March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Erection of detached building to provide replacement garage and garden store | Permitted | 02/06/2017 |
| 17/00991/F | 30/05/2017 | Full Development | March House March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Alterations to access and entrance gates | Permitted | 24/07/2017 |
| 16/02058/F | 27/10/2016 | Full Development | March House March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Erection of replacement garage and garden store with home office over | Refused | 22/12/2016 |
| 19/00041/DISC | 29/01/2019 | Discharge Of Conditions | March House March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Discharge of Conditions 3 (external walls and roof), 5 (arboricultural method statement) and 6 (parking and manoeuvring areas) of 17/00793/F | Permitted | 26/03/2019 |
| 20/00083/TPO | 14/01/2020 | Works To Tree Preservation Order | March House March Road Mollington OX17 1BP | Trees T1, T5, T6 - 3 No. Beech - Remove to ground. Reason: Due to concerns over stability and risk posed to property. Tree T2 - Prune lowest south east lateral branch to source. Reason: To avoid contact with the building. Trees T9 - T11 - 3 No. Poplar - Reduce to around 12m height. Reason: To reduce risk posed to highway and to allow safer long term retention and screening value. Tree T12 - Poplar - Remove to ground. Reason - Due to concerns of stability and risk posed to highway - Subject to TPO 24/2017 Replanting: Plant 5 No Trees (3 No. Golden Irish Yew and 2 No. Pear) in the area closest the property on the west side of the driveway to replacer fallen Beech and Trees T1, T5, T6. To be sourced as 2-3m high pot grown, light standards. Plant 1 No. Common Lime in the area to front of the property to replace T12. To be sourced as 2-3m high pot grown | Permitted | 17/03/2020 |
| 21/03207/TPO | 20/09/2021 | Works To Tree Preservation Order | March House March Road Mollington OX17 1BP | T1 (Scots Pine) - Remove to near ground to remove the risk posed to the highway by poor structural form and exposure - subject to TPO 24/2017 | Permitted | 19/11/2021 |
| 23/02184/TPO_5 | 07/08/2023 | TPO - 5 Day Notice | March House March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | T1 - Silver birch – dead. Replant 1no. Persian ironwood T2 - Sycamore – almost dead- less than 5% live growth, sporadic through lower crown, Replant 1no. Sweet gum | Permitted | 07/08/2023 |
| 24/00425/TPO | 16/02/2024 | Works To Tree Preservation Order | March House March Road Mollington Oxfordshire OX17 1BP | Tree: Shown as T4 on supplied plan - Silver birch tree growing to front of property and west of driveway entrance. Works: Remove to ground. Reason: Due to concerns of stability as result of honey fungus having been present in the area and resulting in death of adjacent birch (removed in 2023) which has left tree exposed. Replant: 1no. southern beech, Nothofagus antarctica, 3-4m high in open space to front of property and west of driveway (same garden area). Subject to TPO 24/2017 (G2) and 005/1993 (A1) | Permitted | 12/04/2024 |
| 24/02824/TPO | 24/10/2024 | Works To Tree Preservation Order | March House March Road Mollington Oxfordshire OX17 1BP | G1 - 4no Poplar - Re-pollard to old pruning points (c12-14m height) due to concerns regarding branch loss and potential for damage to adjacent garage and potential to affect the highway - subject to TPO 24/2017 | Permitted | 07/01/2025 |
Appeal Applications | ||||||
| Appeal number | Appeal Start Date | Appeal Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17/00001/REFAPP | 31/01/2017 | Appeal against Refusal | March House March Road Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Erection of replacement garage and garden store with home office over | Appeal Dismissed | |
Building Control Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Received Date | Validated Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 08/00278/DOMFP | 10/03/2008 | 13/03/2008 | Full Plans | March House Main Street Mollington Banbury Oxfordshire OX17 1BP | Demolition of existing bungalow and construction of new house (excluding fireplace appliance and hearth) | |
| CP/OFTEC/00129/2009 | 14/10/2009 | 14/10/2009 | Oil Firing Technical Association | March House Main Street Mollington Banbury Oxfordshire OX17 1BP | Install oil storage & supply facility External Install room sealed balanced flued pressure jet appliance Garage Install wet central heating system & controls Garage Commission central heating system & controls Utility | |
| CP/HETAS/00774/2014 | 23/02/2012 | 23/02/2012 | Heating Equip Testing and Approval Schem | March House Main Street Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Other Dry Roomheater/Stove Dry System Only New Insulated Factory Made Chimney System New Hearth/Surround | |
| CP/HETAS/00354/2017 | 26/03/2017 | 26/03/2017 | Heating Equip Testing and Approval Schem | March House March Lane Mollington Banbury OX17 1BP | Installed Hwam Euroheat Distributors (H.B.S) Ltd: 2620 | |