Menu

Planning register

Planning Appeal - 23/00088/REF

Skip to tab headings. Skip to tab content.


Back to results New search


Reference Number
23/00088/REF
 Planning Inspectorate Reference
APP/C3105/W/23/3325113
Location
Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Heath Close Milcombe OX15 4RZ
Proposal
Erection of 35 two storey dwelling houses, construction of access off Rye Hill, together with garaging, parking, open space with LAP, landscaping and all enabling works
Status
Appeal Determined
 Parish
Milcombe
 Ward
Deddington
Start Date
08/08/2023
 Comments to PINS Due
12/12/2023
 Appeal Procedure
Hearing
Planning Case Officer
Katherine Daniels
 Phone
01295 753 736
Appeals Case Officer
Email
Phone
Venue (if applicable)
Council Chamber, Bodicote House, Bodicote, Banbury, OX15 4AA
 Decision
Appeal Allowed
 Decision Date
12/12/2023

To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.

Document Type Date Description File Size Drawing/Rev Number
Appeal Documents
Appellants Evidence 08/11/2023 Completed Agreement 8Nov2023 - Land West of Heath Cl Milcombe (015709).pdf (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 25/09/2023 Appellant's additional appeal decision Appendix 3313440 Kempsey Worcestershire (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 25/09/2023 Appellant's additional appeal decision Appendix 3310788 Grove, Oxfordshire (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 16/10/2023 Appellant Response To LPA's Costs Rebuttal (Milcombe) (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 16/10/2023 Costs Application 2 of 2 (Milcombe Final Version) (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 16/10/2023 Annex A Appeal Decision 3278536 (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 16/10/2023 Annex B 22.01976.out Officer Report (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 16/10/2023 Annex B Public Minutes 09022023 1600 Planning Committee (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 16/10/2023 Annex B Site Boundary Plan (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 01/11/2023 2202104F Milcombe Proposed conditions at appeal - Final version 31.10.2023.docx (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 01/11/2023 MIL-PL56A - Open Space Plan.pdf (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appeal Statement Of Case Milcombe (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 1 Commitee Report Application Ref 22.02104.f (february 2023) (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 2 Counsel Opinion On Application Ref 22.02104.f (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 3 Planning Committee Minutes 9 February 2023 (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 4 Committee Report Application Ref 22.02104.f (15th June 2023) (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 5 Decision Notice Ref 22.02104.f (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 6 Committee Report Application Ref 15.02068.out (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 7 Decision Notice Ref 15.02068.out (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 8 Cherwell Final Helaa 2018 (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 8 Housing And Economic Needs Assessment Final Report (december 2022) (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 9 Cherwell Housing Land Supply Position Statement 2022 2027 (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 10 Statement Re Cherwells Five Year Hls (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Appendix 11 Hook Norton Appeal Decision (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Costs Application 1 of 2 (Milcombe) (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Costs Application Annex A 22.01976.out Officer Report (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Costs Application Annex A Public Minutes 09022023 1600 Planning Committee (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Costs Application Annex A Site Boundary Plan (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 Statement Of Common Ground Milcombe (Initial Draft) June 2023 (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 09/08/2023 01 Appeal Form 923452 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 25/10/2023 SUPERSEDED Proposed conditions at appeal - Final version 24.10.2023 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 25/10/2023 Agent's agreement to pre-commencement conditions (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 25/10/2023 Public Art, Indoor Sport, Outdoor Sport, Village Hall updated 25.10.2023.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 25/10/2023 Landscape CIL Justification (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 18/09/2023 Council SoC - Revised Appendices list for PINS (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 18/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 2B - Swere Valley and Upper Stour Conservation Target Area Detailed Report (Updated 2019).pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 18/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 22 - Proof of Evidence on 5YHLS on behalf of CDC for NW Bicester PINS Ref 3315849.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 18/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 23 - Rebuttal Proof of Evidence on 5YHLS on behalf of CDC for NW Bicester PINS Ref 3315849.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 18/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 24 - 2023 NW Bicester appeal decision 3315849.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 18/10/2023 CDC Proposed Conditions at Appeal 17.10.2023 Draft - drainage to be resolved (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 18/10/2023 CDC S106 Agreement Milcombe 16.10.2023 Draft - drainage to be resolved (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 17/10/2023 Statement of Common Ground 5YHLS (final) (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 17/10/2023 Second response to appellant's revised cost claim 17.10.2023 Final (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 17/10/2023 Second response to appellant's revised costs claim - Fringford appeal decision (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 17/10/2023 PINS query re: Plan list in proposed condition 2 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 09/10/2023 LPA rebuttal of Appellant's Cost Claim 09.10.2023 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 15/10/2023 Statement of Common Ground - Milcombe (Final Agreed Draft).pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 15/10/2023 2202104F Milcombe committee report S106 section including LAP 15.06.2023.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 15/10/2023 Education Waste Public Transport.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 15/10/2023 Health BOB Integrated Care Board 11.01.2023.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 15/10/2023 Public Art Indoor Sport Outdoor Sport Village Hall 09.08.2022.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 15/10/2023 Affordable Housing 08.02.2023.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Milcombe SoC 12.09.2023 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 1 Decision Notice 2202104F (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 2 Swere Valley and Upper Stour Conservation Target Area Main Report (July 2006) (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 3 Regulation 10a Planning Policy Review And Housing Land Supply Statement (February 2023) (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 4 Housing And Economic Land Availability Assessment (helaa) February 2018 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 5 Adopted Cherwell Local Plan 2011-2031 Part 1 Partial Review (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 6 Cherwell LP 2011-2031 Part 1 Partial Review Oxfords Unmet Need Aug 2020 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 7 Oxfordshire Housing And Economic Needs Assessment (December 2022) (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 8 Draft Cherwell Local Plan Review 2040 (Regulation 18) Consultation (16 Aug 2023) (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 9 R(Rank) v E Cambs [2002] EWHC 2081 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 10 2015 Kirtlington Appeal Decision 3001612 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 11 2015 Hook Norton Appeal Decision 2226552 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 12 2016 Chesterton Appeal Decision 3130576 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 13 2017 Weston On The Green Appeal Decision 3158925 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 14 2018 Launton Appeal Decision 3188671 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 15 2018 Finmere Appeal Decision 3189420 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 16 2019 Ambrosden Appeal Decision 3228169 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 17 2019 Bodicote Appeal Decision 3222428 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 18 2019 Sibford Ferris Appeal Decision 3229631 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 19 2021 Adderbury Appeal Decision 3255419 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 20 DLUHC Land Use Statistics England 2022 (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 12/09/2023 Council SoC - Appendix 21 Countrywide Design Summary (June 1998) (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 31/10/2023 REVISED Proposed conditions at appeal - Final version 31.10.2023 (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 31/10/2023 LPA email to PINS with revised conditions list (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 18/10/2023 Hearing Agenda 18.10.2023 (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 24/10/2023 CDC Proposed Conditions at Appeal Final Version 24.10.2023 (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 09/08/2023 N'bour Notification 1 (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 09/08/2023 Start Letter from PINS (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 10/08/2023 Hearing Details (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 15/08/2023 Start Letter 08.08.2023. (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 CDC Strategic Housing Officer (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 NHS Buckinghamshire, Oxfordshire, Berkshire West Integrated Care Board covering email (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 OCC Archaeology covering email (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group response (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Gillian Cooke Objection 22 08 2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Policy H18 of Cherwell LP 1996 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 John Graham Objection 03 08 2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 List Of Consultees (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 List Of Neighbours (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Local Plan 1996 Title And Front Page (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Local Plan 2011 2031 Title And Front Page (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Neighbour 1 Letter (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Objection Flooding photographs 2004 to 2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Paul Gee Objection 07 08 2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 CDC Community Infrastructure consultation response (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Policy Bsc 1 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Policy Bsc 2 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Policy Inf 1 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Policy Villages 1 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Policy Villages 2 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Public Minutes 09 Feb 2023 1600 Planning Committee (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Public Minutes 15 June 2023 1600 Planning Committee (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Questionnaire 935600 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 OCC Highways consultation response 01.09.2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 OCC Highways and LLFA consultation responses 11 and 16.11.2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 OCC LLFA consultation response 30.11.2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 OCC LLFA consultation response 15.12.2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 OCC Highways and Archaeology consultation responses 26 and 20.04.2023 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Robert Gardner (on Behalf Of Mrs S Grant) Objection 19 09 2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Site Notice 2202104f (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Tvp Response 22 02104 F Jan23(1) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Tvp Response 22 02104 F Jan23 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Tvp Response 22 02104 F May23 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Tvp Response 22 02104 F (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 12heath Objection(1) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 17 08 16 External Consultation Checklist V3.3 Update(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 22 02104 F Advice(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe (railway)(1)(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe (railway)(2)(1) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe (railway)(4) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 20220520 083753(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 20220529 090924 (1)(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Adopted Developer Contributions February 2018(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Andrew Scott Objection 16 08 2022(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Banbury Guardian 18.08.2022(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Barbara Clifton Objection 14 08 2022(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Bbowt Response To 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Bob Icb Planning Application Response 22 02104 F(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Case Officers Report(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Objection - 11 Heath Close (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Chris Hill Objection 22 08 2022(2) (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Consultee Comments - Ecology 14/09/2022 13:57:18 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Consultee Comments - Ecology 15/12/2022 14:25:35 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Consultee Comments - Land Drainage 24/04/2023 14:55:50 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Consultee Comments - Land Drainage 28/04/2023 08:19:17 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Consultee Comments - Land Drainage 03/08/2022 09:46:03 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Notification 1 Letter (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Thames Water 3 August 2022 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Strategic Housing 08 February 2023 14:37 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Enviromental Health 19 May 2023 18:42 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Enviromental Health 15 August 2022 15:45 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email BOB ICB 24 August 2022 17:44 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Oxfordshire County Archaeological Services 09 August 2022 16:09 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Naturespace Gcn Comments 05 August 2022 16:55 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Enviroment Agency 18 August 2022 16:24 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 09/08/2023 Email Milcombe Parish Council 18 August 2022 15:03 (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 12/09/2023 OCC's Reg 122 Statement (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 18/10/2023 PINS rejection of Milcombe Parish Council evidence (0kb) -
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision 12/12/2023 3325113 appeal decision.pdf 12.12.2023. (0kb) -
Decision 12/12/2023 3325113 cost decision.pdf (0kb) -
Appeals Documents
0.jpg 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - 0.jpg (0kb) -
1.jpg 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - 1.jpg (0kb) -
2.jpg 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - 2.jpg (0kb) -
3.jpg 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - 3.jpg (0kb) -
4.jpg 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - 4.jpg (0kb) -
5.jpg 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - 5.jpg (0kb) -
8220308_6102_B.pdf 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - 8220308_6102_B.pdf (0kb) -
Admin & Monitoring Fees 1st April 2023 - 31st March 2024.xlsx 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - Admin & Monitoring Fees 1st April 2023 - 31st March 2024.xlsx (0kb) -
MIL-PL01A Boundary Plan(1).pdf 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL01A Boundary Plan.pdf (0kb) -
MIL-PL02P Milcombe Colour Site Plan.pdf 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL02P Milcombe Colour Site Plan.pdf (0kb) -
MIL-PL55F - Tenure Plan(1).pdf 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL55F - Tenure Plan.pdf (0kb) -
MIL-PL56A - Open Space Plan(2).pdf 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL56A - Open Space Plan.pdf (0kb) -
S106 Agreement Milcombe final clean.docx 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe - S106 Agreement Milcombe final clean.docx (0kb) -
Email-S106 Milcombe.msg 02/11/2023 S106 Milcombe (0kb) -
Appeal Documents
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Completed Agreement 8Nov2023 - Land West of Heath Cl Milcombe (015709).pdf
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant's additional appeal decision Appendix 3313440 Kempsey Worcestershire
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant's additional appeal decision Appendix 3310788 Grove, Oxfordshire
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant Response To LPA's Costs Rebuttal (Milcombe)
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Costs Application 2 of 2 (Milcombe Final Version)
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Annex A Appeal Decision 3278536
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Annex B 22.01976.out Officer Report
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Annex B Public Minutes 09022023 1600 Planning Committee
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Annex B Site Boundary Plan
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - 2202104F Milcombe Proposed conditions at appeal - Final version 31.10.2023.docx
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - MIL-PL56A - Open Space Plan.pdf
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appeal Statement Of Case Milcombe
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 1 Commitee Report Application Ref 22.02104.f (february 2023)
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 2 Counsel Opinion On Application Ref 22.02104.f
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 3 Planning Committee Minutes 9 February 2023
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 4 Committee Report Application Ref 22.02104.f (15th June 2023)
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 5 Decision Notice Ref 22.02104.f
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 6 Committee Report Application Ref 15.02068.out
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 7 Decision Notice Ref 15.02068.out
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 8 Cherwell Final Helaa 2018
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 8 Housing And Economic Needs Assessment Final Report (december 2022)
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 9 Cherwell Housing Land Supply Position Statement 2022 2027
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 10 Statement Re Cherwells Five Year Hls
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appendix 11 Hook Norton Appeal Decision
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Costs Application 1 of 2 (Milcombe)
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Costs Application Annex A 22.01976.out Officer Report
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Costs Application Annex A Public Minutes 09022023 1600 Planning Committee
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Costs Application Annex A Site Boundary Plan
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Statement Of Common Ground Milcombe (Initial Draft) June 2023
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - 01 Appeal Form 923452
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - SUPERSEDED Proposed conditions at appeal - Final version 24.10.2023
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Agent's agreement to pre-commencement conditions
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Public Art, Indoor Sport, Outdoor Sport, Village Hall updated 25.10.2023.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Landscape CIL Justification
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Revised Appendices list for PINS
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 2B - Swere Valley and Upper Stour Conservation Target Area Detailed Report (Updated 2019).pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 22 - Proof of Evidence on 5YHLS on behalf of CDC for NW Bicester PINS Ref 3315849.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 23 - Rebuttal Proof of Evidence on 5YHLS on behalf of CDC for NW Bicester PINS Ref 3315849.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 24 - 2023 NW Bicester appeal decision 3315849.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - CDC Proposed Conditions at Appeal 17.10.2023 Draft - drainage to be resolved
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - CDC S106 Agreement Milcombe 16.10.2023 Draft - drainage to be resolved
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Statement of Common Ground 5YHLS (final)
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Second response to appellant's revised cost claim 17.10.2023 Final
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Second response to appellant's revised costs claim - Fringford appeal decision
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - PINS query re: Plan list in proposed condition 2
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA rebuttal of Appellant's Cost Claim 09.10.2023
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Statement of Common Ground - Milcombe (Final Agreed Draft).pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - 2202104F Milcombe committee report S106 section including LAP 15.06.2023.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Education Waste Public Transport.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Health BOB Integrated Care Board 11.01.2023.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Public Art Indoor Sport Outdoor Sport Village Hall 09.08.2022.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Affordable Housing 08.02.2023.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Milcombe SoC 12.09.2023
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 1 Decision Notice 2202104F
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 2 Swere Valley and Upper Stour Conservation Target Area Main Report (July 2006)
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 3 Regulation 10a Planning Policy Review And Housing Land Supply Statement (February 2023)
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 4 Housing And Economic Land Availability Assessment (helaa) February 2018
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 5 Adopted Cherwell Local Plan 2011-2031 Part 1 Partial Review
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 6 Cherwell LP 2011-2031 Part 1 Partial Review Oxfords Unmet Need Aug 2020
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 7 Oxfordshire Housing And Economic Needs Assessment (December 2022)
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 8 Draft Cherwell Local Plan Review 2040 (Regulation 18) Consultation (16 Aug 2023)
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 9 R(Rank) v E Cambs [2002] EWHC 2081
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 10 2015 Kirtlington Appeal Decision 3001612
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 11 2015 Hook Norton Appeal Decision 2226552
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 12 2016 Chesterton Appeal Decision 3130576
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 13 2017 Weston On The Green Appeal Decision 3158925
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 14 2018 Launton Appeal Decision 3188671
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 15 2018 Finmere Appeal Decision 3189420
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 16 2019 Ambrosden Appeal Decision 3228169
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 17 2019 Bodicote Appeal Decision 3222428
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 18 2019 Sibford Ferris Appeal Decision 3229631
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 19 2021 Adderbury Appeal Decision 3255419
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 20 DLUHC Land Use Statistics England 2022
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Council SoC - Appendix 21 Countrywide Design Summary (June 1998)
Miscellaneous (0kb) - REVISED Proposed conditions at appeal - Final version 31.10.2023
Miscellaneous (0kb) - LPA email to PINS with revised conditions list
Miscellaneous (0kb) - Hearing Agenda 18.10.2023
Miscellaneous (0kb) - CDC Proposed Conditions at Appeal Final Version 24.10.2023
Miscellaneous (0kb) - N'bour Notification 1
Miscellaneous (0kb) - Start Letter from PINS
Miscellaneous (0kb) - Hearing Details
Miscellaneous (0kb) - Start Letter 08.08.2023.
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - CDC Strategic Housing Officer
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - NHS Buckinghamshire, Oxfordshire, Berkshire West Integrated Care Board covering email
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - OCC Archaeology covering email
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group response
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Gillian Cooke Objection 22 08 2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Policy H18 of Cherwell LP 1996
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - John Graham Objection 03 08 2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - List Of Consultees
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - List Of Neighbours
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 Title And Front Page
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Local Plan 2011 2031 Title And Front Page
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Neighbour 1 Letter
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Objection Flooding photographs 2004 to 2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Paul Gee Objection 07 08 2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - CDC Community Infrastructure consultation response
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Policy Bsc 1
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Policy Bsc 2
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Policy Inf 1
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Policy Villages 1
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Policy Villages 2
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Public Minutes 09 Feb 2023 1600 Planning Committee
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Public Minutes 15 June 2023 1600 Planning Committee
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Questionnaire 935600
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - OCC Highways consultation response 01.09.2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - OCC Highways and LLFA consultation responses 11 and 16.11.2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - OCC LLFA consultation response 30.11.2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - OCC LLFA consultation response 15.12.2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - OCC Highways and Archaeology consultation responses 26 and 20.04.2023
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Robert Gardner (on Behalf Of Mrs S Grant) Objection 19 09 2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Site Notice 2202104f
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Tvp Response 22 02104 F Jan23(1)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Tvp Response 22 02104 F Jan23
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Tvp Response 22 02104 F May23
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Tvp Response 22 02104 F
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 12heath Objection(1)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 17 08 16 External Consultation Checklist V3.3 Update(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 22 02104 F Advice(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe (railway)(1)(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe (railway)(2)(1)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe (railway)(4)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 20220520 083753(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 20220529 090924 (1)(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Adopted Developer Contributions February 2018(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Andrew Scott Objection 16 08 2022(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Banbury Guardian 18.08.2022(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Barbara Clifton Objection 14 08 2022(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Bbowt Response To 2202104f Heath Close Milcombe(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Bob Icb Planning Application Response 22 02104 F(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Case Officers Report(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Objection - 11 Heath Close
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Chris Hill Objection 22 08 2022(2)
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Consultee Comments - Ecology 14/09/2022 13:57:18
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Consultee Comments - Ecology 15/12/2022 14:25:35
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Consultee Comments - Land Drainage 24/04/2023 14:55:50
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Consultee Comments - Land Drainage 28/04/2023 08:19:17
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Consultee Comments - Land Drainage 03/08/2022 09:46:03
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Notification 1 Letter
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Thames Water 3 August 2022
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Strategic Housing 08 February 2023 14:37
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Enviromental Health 19 May 2023 18:42
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Enviromental Health 15 August 2022 15:45
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email BOB ICB 24 August 2022 17:44
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Oxfordshire County Archaeological Services 09 August 2022 16:09
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Naturespace Gcn Comments 05 August 2022 16:55
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Enviroment Agency 18 August 2022 16:24
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Email Milcombe Parish Council 18 August 2022 15:03
Third Party Representations (0kb) - OCC's Reg 122 Statement
Third Party Representations (0kb) - PINS rejection of Milcombe Parish Council evidence
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision (0kb) - 3325113 appeal decision.pdf 12.12.2023.
Decision (0kb) - 3325113 cost decision.pdf
Planning Application Documents
0.jpg (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - 0.jpg
1.jpg (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - 1.jpg
2.jpg (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - 2.jpg
3.jpg (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - 3.jpg
4.jpg (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - 4.jpg
5.jpg (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - 5.jpg
8220308_6102_B.pdf (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - 8220308_6102_B.pdf
Admin & Monitoring Fees 1st April 2023 - 31st March 2024.xlsx (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - Admin & Monitoring Fees 1st April 2023 - 31st March 2024.xlsx
MIL-PL01A Boundary Plan(1).pdf (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL01A Boundary Plan.pdf
MIL-PL02P Milcombe Colour Site Plan.pdf (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL02P Milcombe Colour Site Plan.pdf
MIL-PL55F - Tenure Plan(1).pdf (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL55F - Tenure Plan.pdf
MIL-PL56A - Open Space Plan(2).pdf (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - MIL-PL56A - Open Space Plan.pdf
S106 Agreement Milcombe final clean.docx (0kb) - S106 Milcombe - S106 Agreement Milcombe final clean.docx
Email-S106 Milcombe.msg (0kb) - S106 Milcombe

Planning Applications

Application number Valid Date Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Issued Date
22/02104/F 01/08/2022 Full Development Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Heath Close Milcombe OX15 4RZ Erection of 35 two storey dwelling houses, construction of access off Rye Hill, together with garaging, parking, open space with LAP, landscaping and all enabling works Appeal Allowed (Against Refusal) 19/06/2023
24/01325/DISC 15/05/2024 Discharge Of Conditions Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Heath Close Milcombe Discharge of Conditions 3 (proposed parking provision), 4 (Construction Method Statement), 5 (Construction Traffic Management Plan), 6 (Arboricultural Method Statement), 8 (open space/play space), 10 (great crested newt compensation), 11 (Archaeological Written Scheme of Investigation), 13 (potential contaminative uses) and 26 (drainage phasing plan) of 22/02104/F (allowed on appeal ref: APP/C3105/W/23/3325113) Permitted 10/12/2024
25/00535/M106 03/03/2025 Application to Modify a Section 106 Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Heath Close Milcombe Deed of Variation to amend the s106 for 22/02104/F - To amend the MIP clause to ensure my client can charge the AH units at MVST. To insert an enforceability clause which excludes liability from the RP and RP Mortgagee in respect of the non-AH obligations. To insert an express clause confirming that the rents on AR units can be increased by CPI + 1% per annum To remove reference to HTB Agent as this is no longer in existence. To insert a clause confirming that the AH obligations will not be binding on tenants who have exercised a preserved right to buy. To amend the words “the provisions of paragraph 2 shall not bind” at Paragraph 3 (mortgage exemption) so that the protected parties are wholly excluded from the AH Schedule, as opposed to just Paragraph 3.
25/00728/M106 20/03/2025 Application to Modify a Section 106 Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Heath Close Milcombe Deed of Variation to amend S106 Second Schedule of 22/02104/F - the removal of first homes, to be replaced with shared ownership homes

Appeal Applications

Appeal number Appeal Start Date Appeal Type Location Proposal Decision
23/00088/REF 08/08/2023 Appeal against Refusal Land To The Rear Of No.12 And South Of Dismantled Railway Heath Close Milcombe OX15 4RZ Erection of 35 two storey dwelling houses, construction of access off Rye Hill, together with garaging, parking, open space with LAP, landscaping and all enabling works Appeal Allowed

Back to top.