Planning register

Planning Appeal - 23/00084/REF

Skip to tab headings. Skip to tab content.




Reference Number
23/00084/REF
Planning Inspectorate Reference
APP/C3105/W/23/3314296
Location
Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl Ph Banbury Road North Newington OX15 6AB
Proposal
Erection of one detached dwelling and detached garage
Status
Appeal Determined
Parish
North Newington
Ward
Cropredy, Sibfords And Wroxton
Start Date
19/06/2023
Comments to PINS Due
17/08/2023
Appeal Procedure
Written Reps
Planning Case Officer
James Kirkham
Phone
01295 221896
Appeals Case Officer
Email
Phone
Venue (if applicable)
Decision
Appeal Dismissed
Decision Date
17/08/2023

To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.

Document Type Date Description File Size Drawing/Rev Number
Appeal Documents
Appellants Evidence 21/06/2023 Additional support evidence from Appellant. (0kb) -
Appellants Evidence 10/08/2023 nnAppelant final comment.pdf (0kb) -
Council’s Evidence 25/07/2023 North Newington Appeal Council's Statement of Case.pdf (0kb) -
Miscellaneous 21/06/2023 Start letter (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 21.01561.f Officers Report (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Margaret Allan Objection To Application, June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Margaret Cherry Objection To%0d Application, June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Max Davison Objection 13 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Mcnally Objection June (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Mcnally Planning Objection June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Michael Cherry Objection To%0d Application, June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Neil Wild Objection 07 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Neil Wild Objection 29 07 2021 Combined (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 North Newington Conservation Area (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 North Newington Conservation Area Appraisal May 2014 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Patricia Huxley Objection 14 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Paul Miller Objection 16 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Policy Esd 15 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Printed Minutes 11082022 1600 Planning Committee (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Printed Minutes 14072022 1600 Planning Committee (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Questionnaire 920918 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 R Godfrey Objection 06 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Richard Martinson Objection 08 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Samantha Enstone Objection 30 05 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Stuart Morgan Objection 15 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Susan Barnes Objection To Application, June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Sylvia Pursey Objection To Application June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 27.05.2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 2101561f Officer Rpt (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Alan Moyle Objection 08 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Alex Dawson Objection To Application, June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Appeal Notif Letter (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Christopher Hall Objection 25 05 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Daniel Hart Objection 09 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 David Gutteridge Objection 07 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 David Pursey Objection To Application June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Ellie Objection 15 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 James Taylor Objection 15 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Jessica Brown Objection 18 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Justin Bentley Objection 17 06 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Leeanne Baker Objection To Application June 2021 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 List Of All Plans Allotment Gardens (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 List Of Those Notified About The Appeal (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Local Plan 1996 C28 (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Local Plan 1996 Title And Front Page (0kb) -
Questionnaire Documents 27/06/2023 Local Plan 2011 2031 Title And Front Page (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Alex - 3p attachments 1.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Alex 3p - attahments 3.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Alex 3p attachments 2.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Alex Dawson. - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Anne.B.P.Turner - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Baker L - 930521 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Barnes S - 930109 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Brown J - 923649 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_9529.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_9532.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_9558.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Cherry M - 929209 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023 2.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Huxley P - 930401 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Ingrid Fordred - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 James - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Jangallon - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 John Tasker - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Lesley - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Margaret Morgan - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Mark Howarth - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Morgan S - 929680 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Mr Christopher McNally from North Newington Parish Council - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Nick Brown - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Nicola - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Paul Miller - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Prentis MP V - 930593 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 20230725141658046 (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Rachel Leason - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Roger - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Rufus Dudfield - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Sarah - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Saynor T - 922728 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 T Matthews - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Wild N - 928843 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 20230725141707046 (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Wild N - 928843 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - Sketch elevation drawings to show impact.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023 1.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Claire Crofts - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 cooper p - 925269 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 David Pursey - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 David Robinson - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Dawson A - 929732 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Debby Andrews - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Doidge J - 930578 - INTERESTED PARTY_(PERSONAL).pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Evans O - 930544 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Evans O - 930544 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - Olly Evans Representation against appeal.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Fyfe M - 922749 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Godfrey R - 922838 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Godfrey R - 922838 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - McNally Planning Inspectorate.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Godfrey R - 922838 - INTERESTED PARTY_(PERSONAL).pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Gutteridge D - 922974 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Herlihy T - 930575 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Holford S - 930581 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Holford S - 930581 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_4696.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Holford S - 930581 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - thumbnail_IMG_4695.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023 3.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Williams J - 922935 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Woodward J - 930506 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Yvonne McDonald - 3p.pdf (0kb) -
Third Party Representations 25/07/2023 Zimmer M - 927115 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf (0kb) -
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision 17/08/2023 3314296 Appeal Decision.pdf 17.08.2023 (0kb) -
Appeal Documents
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Additional support evidence from Appellant.
Appellants Evidence (0kb) - nnAppelant final comment.pdf
Council’s Evidence (0kb) - North Newington Appeal Council's Statement of Case.pdf
Miscellaneous (0kb) - Start letter
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 21.01561.f Officers Report
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Margaret Allan Objection To Application, June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Margaret Cherry Objection To%0d Application, June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Max Davison Objection 13 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Mcnally Objection June
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Mcnally Planning Objection June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Michael Cherry Objection To%0d Application, June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Neil Wild Objection 07 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Neil Wild Objection 29 07 2021 Combined
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - North Newington Conservation Area
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - North Newington Conservation Area Appraisal May 2014
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Patricia Huxley Objection 14 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Paul Miller Objection 16 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Policy Esd 15
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Printed Minutes 11082022 1600 Planning Committee
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Printed Minutes 14072022 1600 Planning Committee
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Questionnaire 920918
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - R Godfrey Objection 06 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Richard Martinson Objection 08 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Samantha Enstone Objection 30 05 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Stuart Morgan Objection 15 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Susan Barnes Objection To Application, June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Sylvia Pursey Objection To Application June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 27.05.2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - 2101561f Officer Rpt
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Alan Moyle Objection 08 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Alex Dawson Objection To Application, June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Appeal Notif Letter
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Christopher Hall Objection 25 05 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Daniel Hart Objection 09 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - David Gutteridge Objection 07 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - David Pursey Objection To Application June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Ellie Objection 15 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - James Taylor Objection 15 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Jessica Brown Objection 18 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Justin Bentley Objection 17 06 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Leeanne Baker Objection To Application June 2021
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - List Of All Plans Allotment Gardens
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - List Of Those Notified About The Appeal
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 C28
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 Title And Front Page
Questionnaire Documents (0kb) - Local Plan 2011 2031 Title And Front Page
Third Party Representations (0kb) - 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Alex - 3p attachments 1.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Alex 3p - attahments 3.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Alex 3p attachments 2.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Alex Dawson. - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Anne.B.P.Turner - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Baker L - 930521 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Barnes S - 930109 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Brown J - 923649 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_9529.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_9532.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Cherry M - 930360 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_9558.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Cherry M - 929209 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023 2.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Huxley P - 930401 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Ingrid Fordred - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - James - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Jangallon - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - John Tasker - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Lesley - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Margaret Morgan - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Mark Howarth - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Morgan S - 929680 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Mr Christopher McNally from North Newington Parish Council - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Nick Brown - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Nicola - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Paul Miller - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Prentis MP V - 930593 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - 20230725141658046
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Rachel Leason - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Roger - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Rufus Dudfield - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Sarah - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Saynor T - 922728 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - T Matthews - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Wild N - 928843 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - 20230725141707046
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Wild N - 928843 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - Sketch elevation drawings to show impact.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023 1.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Claire Crofts - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - cooper p - 925269 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - David Pursey - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - David Robinson - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Dawson A - 929732 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Debby Andrews - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Doidge J - 930578 - INTERESTED PARTY_(PERSONAL).pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Evans O - 930544 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Evans O - 930544 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - Olly Evans Representation against appeal.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Fyfe M - 922749 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Godfrey R - 922838 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Godfrey R - 922838 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - McNally Planning Inspectorate.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Godfrey R - 922838 - INTERESTED PARTY_(PERSONAL).pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Gutteridge D - 922974 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Herlihy T - 930575 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Holford S - 930581 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Holford S - 930581 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - IMG_4696.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Holford S - 930581 - INTERESTED PARTY_(ATTACHMENT) - thumbnail_IMG_4695.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - 211 Statement and 3rd Party Reps - To App or LPA - Sarah Gevaux - 25 Jul 2023 3.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Williams J - 922935 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Woodward J - 930506 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Yvonne McDonald - 3p.pdf
Third Party Representations (0kb) - Zimmer M - 927115 - INTERESTED PARTY.pdf
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision (0kb) - 3314296 Appeal Decision.pdf 17.08.2023

Planning Applications

Application number Valid Date Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Issued Date
01/02487/TCA 14/12/2001 Works To Trees In Conservation Area Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl PH Banbury Road North Newington Banbury Oxon Fell 4 no. Elder and 6 no. Hawthorn and lift crown to 1.8m on 5 no. Hawthorn trees Permitted 21/01/2002
01/02095/OUT 15/10/2001 Outline Application Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl PH Banbury Road North Newington Banbury Oxon Erection of 1 No. new dwelling and new vehicular and pedestrian access (OUTLINE) Application Withdrawn 27/11/2001
02/01103/OUT 23/05/2002 Outline Application Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl PH Banbury Road North Newington Banbury Oxon Erection of 1 No. dwelling and construction of new vehicular and pedestrian access to highway (OUTLINE) Refused 26/07/2002
14/01758/PAO 15/10/2014 Prior Approval Other Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl PH Banbury Road North Newington Change of use from agricultural to B1 business use No Objections 17/12/2014
14/01816/F 23/04/2015 Full Development Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl PH Banbury Road North Newington Erection of 1 No. detached dwelling and detached garage Refused 10/09/2015
21/01561/F 04/05/2021 Full Development Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl Ph Banbury Road North Newington OX15 6AB Erection of one detached dwelling and detached garage Appeal Dismissed (Against Refusal) 12/08/2022
23/02940/PIP 20/10/2023 Permission in Principle Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl PH Banbury Road North Newington Permission in Principle - proposed development range minimum of one and maximum of one single storey dwelling Refused 22/12/2023

Appeal Applications

Appeal number Appeal Start Date Appeal Type Location Proposal Decision
23/00084/REF 19/06/2023 Appeal against Refusal Allotment Gardens West Of Roebuck Inn And South East Of The Blinking Owl Ph Banbury Road North Newington OX15 6AB Erection of one detached dwelling and detached garage Appeal Dismissed

Back to top.