Back to results
New search
| Reference Number 17/00048/REFAPP |
Planning Inspectorate Reference APP/C3105/W/17/3182235 |
| Location Evelyns Farm
Brill Road
Horton Cum Studley
Oxford
OX33 1BZ |
|
| Proposal Demolition of outbuildings; erection of single dwelling house with associated access, landscaping and hardstanding |
|
| Status Appeal Determined |
Parish Horton Cum Studley |
Ward Launton And Otmoor |
| Start Date 14/09/2017 |
Comments to PINS Due 27/11/2017 |
Appeal Procedure |
| Planning Case Officer |
Phone |
|
| Appeals Case Officer |
Email |
Phone |
| Venue (if applicable) |
Decision Appeal Dismissed |
Decision Date 27/11/2017 |
To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.
| Document Type | Date | Description | File Size | Drawing/Rev Number | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Forms | |||||
| Application Document | 31/05/2017 | Publicity | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 20/07/2017 | site visit | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 30/05/2017 | Neighbour consult | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 30/05/2017 | Neighbour map | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 26/05/2017 | App form | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 26/05/2017 | Info map | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 26/05/2017 | Listed Building Entry | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Document | 26/05/2017 | Checklist | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Photographs | 07/06/2017 | Site Notice | (0kb) | - | |
| Photographs | 07/06/2017 | Site Notice | (0kb) | - | |
| Photographs | 07/06/2017 | Site Notice | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 26/05/2017 | Design & Access statement | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 26/05/2017 | LVIA part 2 | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 26/05/2017 | LVIA Part 1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Supporting Documents | 26/05/2017 | Geoenvironmental Desk Assessment | (0kb) | - | |
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout | 26/05/2017 | Indicative proposed site plan | (0kb) | - | |
| Site Location Plan | 26/05/2017 | Location plan | (0kb) | - | |
| Existing Plans | |||||
| Plans – Sections/Surveys | 26/05/2017 | Existing site survey plan | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response | 23/06/2017 | Horton cum Strudley Parish Council - 23.06.17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 13/06/2017 | OCC Highways 16/6/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 06/07/2017 | Environmental Protection - 06.07.17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 15/06/2017 | Ecology comments 15/06/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Consultation Response | 13/06/2017 | Natural England comments 13/06/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments | 20/06/2017 | Cuffe, S 18/06/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Public Comments | 26/06/2017 | McNamara, Mr Liam - 26.06.17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report | 13/07/2017 | Refusal - 13.07.17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents | 22/09/2017 | F - Neighbour list | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/10/2017 | 3rd party comments | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/10/2017 | 3rd party comments | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/10/2017 | 3rd party comments | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - Constraints map | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | Saved policies | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | Saved policies | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 27/11/2017 | PINS notice of appeal decision 27/11/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - Consult list | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - Appeal letter | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | PINS notice of appeal start date 14/09/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - LB - EVELYNS FARM NURSERY - Grade 2 10-04-1987 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - History | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - Officer report | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - Site notice | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 19/09/2017 | F - Press notice | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 23/10/2017 | PINS notice of 3rd party comments 20/10/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeal Documents | 03/11/2017 | PINS notice of appellant final comments 03/11/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence | 21/09/2017 | Appellant statement of case - Appendices | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence | 03/11/2017 | Appellant final comments | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence | 21/09/2017 | Appellant statement of case | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 19/09/2017 | LPA Questionnaire | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 19/09/2017 | Appellant appeal form | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 22/09/2017 | F - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 22/09/2017 | F - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 19/09/2017 | F - Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 H18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 19/09/2017 | F - Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 H18 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 23/10/2017 | LPA Statement of case | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 23/10/2017 | LPA Statement of case | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 19/09/2017 | F - Local Plan 2011-2031 ESD 13 ESD 14 ESD 15 Villages1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence | 19/09/2017 | F - Local Plan 2011-2031 ESD 13 ESD 14 ESD 15 Villages1 | (0kb) | - | |
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision | 13/07/2017 | Refusal - 13.07.17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Decision | 27/11/2017 | Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 27/11/17 | (0kb) | - | |
| Application Forms | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Application Document (0kb) - Publicity | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - site visit | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour consult | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour map | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - App form | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Info map | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Listed Building Entry | |||||
| Application Document (0kb) - Checklist | |||||
| Supporting Documents | |||||
| Photographs (0kb) - Site Notice | |||||
| Photographs (0kb) - Site Notice | |||||
| Photographs (0kb) - Site Notice | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - Design & Access statement | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - LVIA part 2 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - LVIA Part 1 | |||||
| Supporting Documents (0kb) - Geoenvironmental Desk Assessment | |||||
| Site Plans | |||||
| Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (0kb) - Indicative proposed site plan | |||||
| Site Location Plan (0kb) - Location plan | |||||
| Existing Plans | |||||
| Plans – Sections/Surveys (0kb) - Existing site survey plan | |||||
| Consultee Responses | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - Horton cum Strudley Parish Council - 23.06.17 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - OCC Highways 16/6/17 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - Environmental Protection - 06.07.17 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - Ecology comments 15/06/17 | |||||
| Consultation Response (0kb) - Natural England comments 13/06/17 | |||||
| Public Comments | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - Cuffe, S 18/06/17 | |||||
| Public Comments (0kb) - McNamara, Mr Liam - 26.06.17 | |||||
| Officer/Committee Consideration | |||||
| Officer Report (0kb) - Refusal - 13.07.17 | |||||
| Appeal Documents | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - Neighbour list | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd party comments | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd party comments | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd party comments | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - Constraints map | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved policies | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appeal decision 27/11/17 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - Consult list | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - Appeal letter | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appeal start date 14/09/17 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - LB - EVELYNS FARM NURSERY - Grade 2 10-04-1987 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - History | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - Officer report | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - Site notice | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - F - Press notice | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of 3rd party comments 20/10/17 | |||||
| Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appellant final comments 03/11/17 | |||||
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant statement of case - Appendices | |||||
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant final comments | |||||
| Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant statement of case | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Questionnaire | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Appellant appeal form | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - F - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 1 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - F - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD 1 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - F - Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 H18 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - F - Local Plan 1996 - C28 C30 H18 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - F - Local Plan 2011-2031 ESD 13 ESD 14 ESD 15 Villages1 | |||||
| Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - F - Local Plan 2011-2031 ESD 13 ESD 14 ESD 15 Villages1 | |||||
| Decision and Legal Agreements | |||||
| Decision (0kb) - Refusal - 13.07.17 | |||||
| Decision (0kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 27/11/17 |
Planning Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Valid Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | Decision Issued Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14/00560/LB | 25/04/2014 | Listed Building | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Conversion of redundant barns with single storey extension to form 1no. 3 bed dwelling with parking | Permitted | 09/07/2014 |
| 14/00521/F | 25/04/2014 | Full Development | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Conversion of redundant barns with single storey extension to form 1no. 3 bed dwelling with parking | Permitted | 09/07/2014 |
| 16/01764/OUT | 02/09/2016 | Outline Application | Former Plant Nursery Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley | Outline - Two sustainable dwelling houses | Refused | 28/10/2016 |
| 15/00376/DISC | 27/08/2015 | Discharge Of Conditions | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Discharge of Conditions 3 & 4 of 14/00560/LB | Permitted | 20/10/2015 |
| 15/00377/DISC | 01/09/2015 | Discharge Of Conditions | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Discharge of Conditions 3, 4 & 7 of 14/00521/F | Permitted | 28/10/2015 |
| 15/02275/LB | 14/12/2015 | Listed Building | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | The refurbishment of the farmhouse, including internal decorating, the removal of both staircases and the introduction of a new, centrally located one necessitating the removal of a partition between hall and kitchen; the replacement of the windows with new conservation-style windows; replacement plumbing & heating; replacement of internal doors. | Permitted | 09/02/2016 |
| 15/02274/F | 15/12/2015 | Full Development | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Replacement of the windows with new conservation-style windows | Permitted | 09/02/2016 |
| 17/00151/DISC | 27/03/2017 | Discharge Of Conditions | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Discharge of Conditions 3 (replacement of kitchen floor) and 4 (replacement of internal doors) of 15/02275/LB | Permitted | 22/05/2017 |
| 17/01095/OUT | 18/05/2017 | Outline Application | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Demolition of outbuildings; erection of single dwelling house with associated access, landscaping and hardstanding | Refused | 13/07/2017 |
| 18/02150/F | 11/12/2018 | Full Development | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Demolition of three asbestos clad industrial units and asbestos clad garage, conversion of indoor pool building and former greenhouse to form a single dwelling together with new garage and work from home office, improved vehicular access and landscaping | Permitted | 23/04/2019 |
| 18/01799/F | 16/10/2018 | Full Development | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Demolition of three asbestos clad industrial units and asbestos clad garage, conversion of indoor pool building and former greenhouse to form a single dwelling together with new garage and work from home office, improved vehicular access and landscaping | Application Withdrawn | 11/12/2018 |
| 17/00833/CLUP | 18/04/2017 | Certificate of Lawful Use Proposed | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley OX33 1BZ | Certificate of Lawfulness of Proposed Use for B1 use of land for buildings and land outlined in red and agricultural use for building and land outlined in blue on Land Use Plan | Application Withdrawn | 13/06/2017 |
| 19/01727/DISC | 05/09/2019 | Discharge Of Conditions | Evelyns Yard Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Discharge of Condition 3 (external cladding materials) of 18/02150/F | Permitted | 31/10/2019 |
Appeal Applications | ||||||
| Appeal number | Appeal Start Date | Appeal Type | Location | Proposal | Decision | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17/00048/REFAPP | 14/09/2017 | Appeal against Refusal | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Demolition of outbuildings; erection of single dwelling house with associated access, landscaping and hardstanding | Appeal Dismissed | |
Building Control Applications | ||||||
| Application number | Received Date | Validated Date | Application Type | Location | Proposal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15/01077/IND | 25/09/2015 | 25/09/2015 | Initial Notice Domestic | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Barn conversion and single storey rear extension | |
| 17/00391/INC | 11/04/2017 | 11/04/2017 | Initial Notice Commercial | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Proposed refurbishment of Farmhouse | |
| CP/HETAS/00076/2019 | 12/02/2019 | 12/02/2019 | Heating Equip Testing and Approval Schem | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Installed A J Wells & Sons: Charnwood C Four Blu with competency Install a biomass dry fuel room heater stove or cooker | |
| CP/OFTEC/00056/2017 | 03/07/2017 | 03/07/2017 | Oil Firing Technical Association | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Installation of an oil fired boiler | |
| CP/NICEIC/01222/2017 | 18/07/2017 | 18/07/2017 | Competent Persons Scheme Type | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Install a replacement consumer unit | |
| 19/00922/IN | 09/09/2019 | Initial Notice | Evelyns Farm Brill Road Horton Cum Studley Oxford OX33 1BZ | Conversion of existing building to form 1No. New dwelling and construction of new garage/annex | ||