Planning register

Planning Appeal - 17/00009/REFAPP

Skip to tab headings. Skip to tab content.




Reference Number
17/00009/REFAPP
Planning Inspectorate Reference
APP/C3105/W/17/3169168
Location
OS Parcel 3498 East Of Heatherstone Lodge Fulwell Road Finmere
Proposal
Residential development and associated infrastructure
Status
Appeal Determined
Parish
Finmere
Ward
Fringford And Heyfords
Start Date
23/03/2017
Comments to PINS Due
14/06/2017
Appeal Procedure
Planning Case Officer
Phone
Appeals Case Officer
Email
Phone
Venue (if applicable)
Decision
Appeal Dismissed
Decision Date
14/06/2017

To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.

Document Type Date Description File Size Drawing/Rev Number
Application Forms
Application Document 18/10/2016 Is EIA necessary (2) (0kb) -
Application Document 13/09/2016 Checklist (0kb) -
Application Document 13/09/2016 Neighbour consult (0kb) -
Application Document 15/09/2016 Publicity (0kb) -
Application Document 26/09/2016 Is EIA necessary (0kb) -
Application Document 22/09/2016 Neighbour consult (0kb) -
Application Document 05/12/2016 site visit (0kb) -
Application Document 22/09/2016 Updated neighbour map (0kb) -
Application Document 09/09/2016 App form (0kb) -
Application Document 09/09/2016 Info map (0kb) -
Application Document 09/09/2016 Neighbour map (0kb) -
Supporting Documents
Flood Risk Assessment 13/09/2016 Flood Risk Assessment (0kb) -
Reports – Miscellaneous 04/10/2016 Appeal decision 01-11-11 (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/09/2016 Travel plan (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/09/2016 Archaeological desk based assessment (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/09/2016 Landscape & Visual Impact Assessment (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/09/2016 Housing planning supporting statement (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 19/04/2017 Geophysical Survey (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/09/2016 Ecological appraisal (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/09/2016 Design & Access statement (0kb) -
Supporting Documents 09/09/2016 Transport statement (0kb) -
Site Plans
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout 22/09/2016 AMD Proposed site layout plan (0kb) -
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout 09/09/2016 Proposed site layout (0kb) -
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout 09/09/2016 Existing site plan (0kb) -
Site Location Plan 09/09/2016 Existing location plan (0kb) -
Proposed Plans
Plans – Miscellaneous 09/09/2016 Proposed site overlay (0kb) -
Consultee Responses
Consultation Response 22/09/2016 Arboricultural officer 20-09-16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 06/10/2016 Arboricultural /Officer/Agent 5/10/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 12/10/2016 Finmere PC 07-10-16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 23/09/2016 Natural England - 23.09.16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 23/09/2016 CDC Business Support Unit - 23.09.16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 22/09/2016 Ecology comments 22-09-16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 27/10/2016 Planning Policy 26/10/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 10/10/2016 Environmental Protection 6/10/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 02/11/2016 Design and Conservation 1/11/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 23/11/2016 OCC - 22.11.16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 24/10/2016 Landscape Architect 21/10/16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 19/09/2016 Thames Water - 16.09.16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 19/09/2016 Waste and Recycling - 15.09.16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 08/11/2016 OCC Archaeology - 04.11.16 (0kb) -
Consultation Response 08/11/2016 OCC Archaeology - 04.11.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments
Public Comments 22/09/2016 Hirst, A 21.09.2016 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Jones SW 03-10-16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Jones SW 03-10-16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Hirst A 04-10-16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 Wynne-Jones, S - 06.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 07/11/2016 Wood EM - 01-11-16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Jansz, K - 08.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Goss, P - 10.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Dayer, M and J - 09.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Andrews C - 03-10-16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 Cottee, J - 04.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 07/10/2016 Dye, H 06.10.2016 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 J Taylor 5/10/16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 J Taylor 5/10/16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Temple, Mr and Mrs - 29.09.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 14/10/2016 Gerard, N - 13.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 Hodgkinson, P and J - 13.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 Face book poll (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 Finmere residents petition (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 S Wynne Jones re petition 12/10/16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 Hirst, A - 12.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 McMullen, S - 12.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 McMullen, E - 12.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 Robinson, B - 12.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 13/10/2016 Knibbs R - 08-10-16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 12/10/2016 Ackland, James and Emily - 12.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 12/10/2016 Hirst, A - 12.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 12/10/2016 Andreasen, M - 12.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 12/10/2016 Kirby, Mr and Mrs - 11.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 20/09/2016 Wood, Mr and Mrs - 19.09.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Finmere Equine Group - 10.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Jansz, C - 08.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 Dye, J - 06.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 Bristow, S - 05.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 22/09/2016 Hirst, A 21.09.2016 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Trice, S - 05.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Darling-Glinski, F - 03.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Baker, V - 04.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 The Rushforth Family - 03.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Wynne-Jones, S - 03.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Wynne-Jones, S - 03.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Wynne-Jones, S - 03.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Pope, R - 03.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Browning, E - 03.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 04/10/2016 Hirst, A - 02.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 21/09/2016 Goodrich, S - 21.09.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 Watson, M - 06.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Reason, S and J - 05.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Newman, J - 05.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Tighe, Mr and Mrs - 04.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Bristow, R - 04.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 05/10/2016 Everest, Mr and Mrs - 04.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 10/10/2016 Cooley 7/10/16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 14/10/2016 Hirst A 14-10-16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 06/10/2016 Cochrane, A - 05.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Chelin, J - 11.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Bagby, Mr and Mrs - 11.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 11/10/2016 Padbury, Andi - 11.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 07/10/2016 White, Mrs - 07.10.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 20/09/2016 Bowman, Mrs - 20.09.16 (0kb) -
Public Comments 20/09/2016 Bowman, Mr - 20.09.16 (0kb) -
Officer/Committee Consideration
Officer Report 28/11/2016 24.11.2016 (0kb) -
Appeal Documents
Appeal Documents 03/05/2017 3rd Party Comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 03/05/2017 3rd Party Comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 03/05/2017 3rd Party Comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 03/05/2017 3rd Party Comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 03/05/2017 3rd Party Comments (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 14/06/2017 PINS notice of appeal Decision 14/06/17 (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Screening opinion 16-00077-SO (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Planning Site notice (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Consultation list (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Saved policies (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Saved policies (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Footpaths map (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Neighbour list / responses (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 Appeal letter (0kb) -
Appeal Documents 28/03/2017 PINS notice of appeal start date 23/03/17 (0kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 28/03/2017 Appeal Statement FV with appendices (0kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 28/03/2017 Response to council 16-01-17 (1) (0kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 10/05/2017 Appellant rebbutal (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 18/04/2017 Additional information supplied 18/04/17 - Following appeal being lodged (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 18/04/2017 Additional information supplied 18/04/17 - Following appeal being lodged (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 28/03/2017 Local Plan 1996 - C8 C28 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 28/03/2017 Local Plan 1996 - C8 C28 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 28/03/2017 Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD1 ESD 6 ESD13 Villages 2 BSC3 BSC11 INF1 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 4 Kirtlington (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 4 Kirtlington (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 3 WoTG (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 3 WoTG (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 2 Kirtlington (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 2 Kirtlington (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 1 Para 95 CLP2031 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case - Appendix 1 Para 95 CLP2031 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 03/05/2017 LPA Statement of case (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 28/03/2017 Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD1 ESD 6 ESD13 Villages 2 BSC3 BSC11 INF1 (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 28/03/2017 LPA Questionniare (0kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 28/03/2017 Appellant appeal form (0kb) -
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision 14/06/2017 Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 14/06/17 (0kb) -
Decision 28/11/2016 28.11.2016 (0kb) -
Appeals Documents
Superseded 09/09/2016 SUPP Proposed site layout with scale bar (0kb) -
Application Forms
Application Document (0kb) - Is EIA necessary (2)
Application Document (0kb) - Checklist
Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour consult
Application Document (0kb) - Publicity
Application Document (0kb) - Is EIA necessary
Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour consult
Application Document (0kb) - site visit
Application Document (0kb) - Updated neighbour map
Application Document (0kb) - App form
Application Document (0kb) - Info map
Application Document (0kb) - Neighbour map
Supporting Documents
Flood Risk Assessment (0kb) - Flood Risk Assessment
Reports – Miscellaneous (0kb) - Appeal decision 01-11-11
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Travel plan
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Archaeological desk based assessment
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Landscape & Visual Impact Assessment
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Housing planning supporting statement
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Geophysical Survey
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Ecological appraisal
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Design & Access statement
Supporting Documents (0kb) - Transport statement
Site Plans
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (0kb) - AMD Proposed site layout plan
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (0kb) - Proposed site layout
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (0kb) - Existing site plan
Site Location Plan (0kb) - Existing location plan
Proposed Plans
Plans – Miscellaneous (0kb) - Proposed site overlay
Consultee Responses
Consultation Response (0kb) - Arboricultural officer 20-09-16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Arboricultural /Officer/Agent 5/10/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Finmere PC 07-10-16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Natural England - 23.09.16
Consultation Response (0kb) - CDC Business Support Unit - 23.09.16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Ecology comments 22-09-16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Planning Policy 26/10/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Environmental Protection 6/10/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Design and Conservation 1/11/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - OCC - 22.11.16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Landscape Architect 21/10/16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Thames Water - 16.09.16
Consultation Response (0kb) - Waste and Recycling - 15.09.16
Consultation Response (0kb) - OCC Archaeology - 04.11.16
Consultation Response (0kb) - OCC Archaeology - 04.11.16
Public Comments
Public Comments (0kb) - Hirst, A 21.09.2016
Public Comments (0kb) - Jones SW 03-10-16
Public Comments (0kb) - Jones SW 03-10-16
Public Comments (0kb) - Hirst A 04-10-16
Public Comments (0kb) - Wynne-Jones, S - 06.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Wood EM - 01-11-16
Public Comments (0kb) - Jansz, K - 08.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Goss, P - 10.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Dayer, M and J - 09.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Andrews C - 03-10-16
Public Comments (0kb) - Cottee, J - 04.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Dye, H 06.10.2016
Public Comments (0kb) - J Taylor 5/10/16
Public Comments (0kb) - J Taylor 5/10/16
Public Comments (0kb) - Temple, Mr and Mrs - 29.09.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Gerard, N - 13.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Hodgkinson, P and J - 13.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Face book poll
Public Comments (0kb) - Finmere residents petition
Public Comments (0kb) - S Wynne Jones re petition 12/10/16
Public Comments (0kb) - Hirst, A - 12.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - McMullen, S - 12.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - McMullen, E - 12.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Robinson, B - 12.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Knibbs R - 08-10-16
Public Comments (0kb) - Ackland, James and Emily - 12.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Hirst, A - 12.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Andreasen, M - 12.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Kirby, Mr and Mrs - 11.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Wood, Mr and Mrs - 19.09.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Finmere Equine Group - 10.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Jansz, C - 08.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Dye, J - 06.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Bristow, S - 05.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Hirst, A 21.09.2016
Public Comments (0kb) - Trice, S - 05.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Darling-Glinski, F - 03.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Baker, V - 04.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - The Rushforth Family - 03.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Wynne-Jones, S - 03.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Wynne-Jones, S - 03.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Wynne-Jones, S - 03.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Pope, R - 03.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Browning, E - 03.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Hirst, A - 02.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Goodrich, S - 21.09.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Watson, M - 06.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Reason, S and J - 05.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Newman, J - 05.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Tighe, Mr and Mrs - 04.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Bristow, R - 04.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Everest, Mr and Mrs - 04.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Cooley 7/10/16
Public Comments (0kb) - Hirst A 14-10-16
Public Comments (0kb) - Cochrane, A - 05.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Chelin, J - 11.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Bagby, Mr and Mrs - 11.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Padbury, Andi - 11.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - White, Mrs - 07.10.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Bowman, Mrs - 20.09.16
Public Comments (0kb) - Bowman, Mr - 20.09.16
Officer/Committee Consideration
Officer Report (0kb) - 24.11.2016
Appeal Documents
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd Party Comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd Party Comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd Party Comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd Party Comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - 3rd Party Comments
Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appeal Decision 14/06/17
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Screening opinion 16-00077-SO
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Planning Site notice
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Consultation list
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved policies
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Saved policies
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Footpaths map
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Neighbour list / responses
Appeal Documents (0kb) - Appeal letter
Appeal Documents (0kb) - PINS notice of appeal start date 23/03/17
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appeal Statement FV with appendices
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Response to council 16-01-17 (1)
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (0kb) - Appellant rebbutal
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Additional information supplied 18/04/17 - Following appeal being lodged
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Additional information supplied 18/04/17 - Following appeal being lodged
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 - C8 C28
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 1996 - C8 C28
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD1 ESD 6 ESD13 Villages 2 BSC3 BSC11 INF1
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 4 Kirtlington
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 4 Kirtlington
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 3 WoTG
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 3 WoTG
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 2 Kirtlington
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 2 Kirtlington
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 1 Para 95 CLP2031
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case - Appendix 1 Para 95 CLP2031
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Statement of case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Local Plan 2011-2031 - ESD1 ESD 6 ESD13 Villages 2 BSC3 BSC11 INF1
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - LPA Questionniare
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (0kb) - Appellant appeal form
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision (0kb) - Appeal Decision - Appeal Dismissed 14/06/17
Decision (0kb) - 28.11.2016
Planning Application Documents
Superseded (0kb) - SUPP Proposed site layout with scale bar

Planning Applications

Application number Valid Date Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Issued Date
16/01209/OUT 13/09/2016 Outline Application OS Parcel 3498 East Of Heatherstone Lodge Fulwell Road Finmere Residential development and associated infrastructure Refused 28/11/2016
17/01328/OUT 27/06/2017 Outline Application OS Parcel 3498 East Of Heatherstone Lodge Fulwell Road Finmere Outline application for residential development Refused 29/09/2017
17/00057/SO 27/06/2017 Screening Opinion OS Parcel 3498 East Of Heatherstone Lodge Fulwell Road Finmere Outline application for residential development Screening Opinion not requesting EIA 25/08/2017

Appeal Applications

Appeal number Appeal Start Date Appeal Type Location Proposal Decision
17/00009/REFAPP 23/03/2017 Appeal against Refusal OS Parcel 3498 East Of Heatherstone Lodge Fulwell Road Finmere Residential development and associated infrastructure Appeal Dismissed
17/00072/REFAPP 14/05/2018 Appeal against Refusal OS Parcel 3498 East Of Heatherstone Lodge Fulwell Road Finmere Outline application for residential development Appeal Dismissed

Back to top.