Planning register

Planning Appeal - 14/00002/REFAPP

Skip to tab headings. Skip to tab content.




Reference Number
14/00002/REFAPP
Planning Inspectorate Reference
APP/C3105/A/14/2212234
Location
Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Banbury OX15 4RQ
Proposal
Erection of a detached dwelling and 3 bay garage
Status
Appeal Determined
Parish
Milcombe
Ward
Bloxham And Bodicote
Start Date
27/01/2014
Comments to PINS Due
16/07/2014
Appeal Procedure
Planning Case Officer
Phone
Appeals Case Officer
Email
Phone
Venue (if applicable)
Decision
Appeal Dismissed
Decision Date
16/07/2014

To view individual documents, click on the highlighted document title. To download a selection of individual documents, place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all the documents, place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files.

Document Type Date Description File Size Drawing/Rev Number
Application Forms
Application Document 31/07/2013 site visit (29kb) -
Application Document 23/05/2013 Site Notice (92kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 info map (273kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 listed building map (185kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 listed building entry (134kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 neighbour map (194kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 neighbour consult (10kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 property history (13kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 checklist/cons/publcity (185kb) -
Application Document 22/05/2013 App form (124kb) -
Supporting Documents
Photographs 31/07/2013 (979kb) -
Supporting Documents 22/05/2013 Design and access statement (4279kb) -
Site Plans
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout 22/05/2013 proposed layout (1302kb) -
Site Location Plan 22/05/2013 (183kb) -
Existing Plans
Plans – Sections/Surveys 22/05/2013 Topographical study (2909kb) -
Proposed Plans
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 22/05/2013 first floor (164kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 22/05/2013 ground floor (129kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 22/05/2013 north/west elevation (200kb) -
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations 22/05/2013 south/east elevation (169kb) -
Plans – Miscellaneous 22/05/2013 courtyard view (132kb) -
Consultee Responses
Consultation Response 07/06/2013 Arbouricultural Officer Comments - 31-05-13 (36kb) -
Consultation Response 01/07/2013 Design & Conservation Officer Comments - 01-07-13 (30kb) -
Consultation Response 13/06/2013 Highways 13/6/13 (17kb) -
Consultation Response 28/05/2013 Thames Water Comments - 28-05-13 (28kb) -
Consultation Response 04/06/2013 Milcombe Parish Council Comments - 04-06-13 (24kb) -
Consultation Response 28/05/2013 County Archaeologist Comments - 28-05-13 (170kb) -
Public Comments
Public Comments 12/06/2013 Rose - Patrick - 11-06-13 (32kb) -
Officer/Committee Consideration
Officer Report 31/07/2013 (373kb) -
Appeal Documents
Appeal Documents 06/06/2014 ASV 6 June 2014 (59kb) -
Appeal Documents 27/01/2014 Appeal start date 22 January 2014 (76kb) -
Appeal Documents 18/07/2014 Correpondence pins - cdc 25 June 2014 (638kb) -
Appeal Documents 12/03/2014 Planning Inspectorate 10/3/14 (30kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 12/03/2014 Written appeal statement of case appendices pt 2 (2381kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 12/03/2014 Written appeal statement of case appendices pt 1 (1821kb) -
Appeals – Appellants Evidence 12/03/2014 Written appeal statement of case (539kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 06/06/2014 Draft conditions (62kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 06/06/2014 Draft conditions (62kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 06/06/2014 Statement of Case (216kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 06/06/2014 Statement of Case (216kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 17/01/2014 (415kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence 27/01/2014 Appeal questionnaire (181kb) -
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision 31/07/2013 31.07.13 (68kb) -
Decision 17/07/2014 Appeal dismissed 16 July 2014 (103kb) -
Application Forms
Application Document (29kb) - site visit
Application Document (92kb) - Site Notice
Application Document (273kb) - info map
Application Document (185kb) - listed building map
Application Document (134kb) - listed building entry
Application Document (194kb) - neighbour map
Application Document (10kb) - neighbour consult
Application Document (13kb) - property history
Application Document (185kb) - checklist/cons/publcity
Application Document (124kb) - App form
Supporting Documents
Photographs (979kb) -
Supporting Documents (4279kb) - Design and access statement
Site Plans
Plans – Block Plan/Site Layout (1302kb) - proposed layout
Site Location Plan (183kb) -
Existing Plans
Plans – Sections/Surveys (2909kb) - Topographical study
Proposed Plans
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (164kb) - first floor
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (129kb) - ground floor
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (200kb) - north/west elevation
Plans – Floor Plans/Elevations (169kb) - south/east elevation
Plans – Miscellaneous (132kb) - courtyard view
Consultee Responses
Consultation Response (36kb) - Arbouricultural Officer Comments - 31-05-13
Consultation Response (30kb) - Design & Conservation Officer Comments - 01-07-13
Consultation Response (17kb) - Highways 13/6/13
Consultation Response (28kb) - Thames Water Comments - 28-05-13
Consultation Response (24kb) - Milcombe Parish Council Comments - 04-06-13
Consultation Response (170kb) - County Archaeologist Comments - 28-05-13
Public Comments
Public Comments (32kb) - Rose - Patrick - 11-06-13
Officer/Committee Consideration
Officer Report (373kb) -
Appeal Documents
Appeal Documents (59kb) - ASV 6 June 2014
Appeal Documents (76kb) - Appeal start date 22 January 2014
Appeal Documents (638kb) - Correpondence pins - cdc 25 June 2014
Appeal Documents (30kb) - Planning Inspectorate 10/3/14
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (2381kb) - Written appeal statement of case appendices pt 2
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (1821kb) - Written appeal statement of case appendices pt 1
Appeals – Appellants Evidence (539kb) - Written appeal statement of case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (62kb) - Draft conditions
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (62kb) - Draft conditions
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (216kb) - Statement of Case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (216kb) - Statement of Case
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (415kb) -
Appeals – Council’s Evidence (181kb) - Appeal questionnaire
Decision and Legal Agreements
Decision (68kb) - 31.07.13
Decision (103kb) - Appeal dismissed 16 July 2014

Planning Applications

Application number Valid Date Application Type Location Proposal Decision Decision Issued Date
09/00338/REM 12/03/2009 Matters Arising From Outline Approval Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ Reserved Matters (Outline Ref: 07/01366/OUT): Two dwellings with garages and access. Permitted 07/05/2009
07/01366/OUT 03/07/2007 Outline Application Land At Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ OUTLINE application for 2 No. dwellings with garages and access. Refused 28/08/2007
11/01589/F 18/10/2011 Full Development Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ 4 No detached dwellings with garages, parking and private access drive. Refused 30/01/2012
11/01590/LB 18/10/2011 Listed Building Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ Restoration of listed piers and wall and demolition of outbuilding. Permitted 13/12/2011
13/00676/F 07/05/2013 Full Development Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Banbury OX15 4RQ Erection of a detached dwelling and 3 bay garage Refused 31/07/2013
22/00484/F 18/02/2022 Full Development Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Banbury OX15 4RQ Erection of a single dwelling and garage with associated landscaping Permitted 09/06/2022
23/02540/DISC 20/09/2023 Discharge Of Conditions Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ Discharge of Condition 7 (Archaeological Watching Brief) of 22/00484/F Permitted 13/11/2023
23/02596/DISC 25/09/2023 Discharge Of Conditions Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ Discharge of Condition 4 (Landscaping Scheme) of 22/00484/F Permitted 10/11/2023
23/02703/DISC 28/09/2023 Discharge Of Conditions Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ Discharge of Condition 3 (schedule of materials) of 22/00484/F Permitted 19/02/2024
23/03442/NMA 06/12/2023 Non Material Amendments Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ (1) Omit timber shingle from garage; add local ironstone; (2) Change from four closed bays to two open bays and two bays with doors with glazing; (3) Change from mono pitched roof to a dual pitched roof (proposed as non-material amendments to 22/00484/F) Permitted 23/01/2024
24/01250/NMA 07/05/2024 Non Material Amendments Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ 1. Amendment to roof material on garage from Goosewing Grey Trisomet 333 Box Profile to Anthracite grey (RAL7016) Thomas panels box profile sheets; 2. Inclusion of single personnel door between enclosed garage and hovel area, 3. Omit stone lining to hovel side walls (proposed as non-material amendments to 22/00484/F) Permitted 04/06/2024
25/01045/NMA 17/04/2025 Non Material Amendments Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ 1. Change to material specification, 2. Amendments and changes to position of doors and windows, 3. Amendments to overhang on roof (proposed as non-material amendments to 22/00484/F) Permitted 04/06/2025
25/01170/DISC 07/05/2025 Discharge Of Conditions Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ Discharge of Condition 3 (materials and finishes) of 22/00484/F

Appeal Applications

Appeal number Appeal Start Date Appeal Type Location Proposal Decision
14/00002/REFAPP 27/01/2014 Appeal against Refusal Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Banbury OX15 4RQ Erection of a detached dwelling and 3 bay garage Appeal Dismissed

Building Control Applications

Application number Received Date Validated Date Application Type Location Proposal
09/00364/DOMFP 11/05/2009 13/05/2009 Full Plans Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Oxfordshire OX15 4RQ Construction of 2 new 4 bed dwellings
24/46917/CP 12/11/2024 24/10/2024 Competent Persons Scheme Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Banbury OX15 4RQ Circuit alteration or addition in a special location.
24/47577/CP 02/12/2024 18/11/2024 Competent Persons Scheme Milcombe Hall Horton Lane Milcombe Banbury OX15 4RQ Installation of an oil fired boiler.

Back to top.